wand

This prop makes a lot of sense to me - blending traditional Japanese art with the decentralized innovation of Nouns. The focus on accessibility and inclusion through workshops, a rewashable physical coloring book NFT and a Farcaster gallery is a great way to proliferate Nouns to a wider audience.

this is a great proposal that could bring a lot of value to the nouns community. the proposal could be improved by highlighting the team's experience in a way that emphasizes how this will directly impact nouns.

The proposal contains a lot of detail and I am excited to see this in action. It's nice to see a proposal that is trying to use Nouns to help people in more than one country. I feel like this is the type of project that really aligns with Nouns' ethos and will be really impactful for the community.

This proposal does not seem to be focused on the Nouns community, making it too broad for the scope of the project. A focus on how it specifically benefits the Nouns community would be a good first step to improve the proposal.

I find it difficult to believe that this proposal can be successfully executed without significant issues, and I think it might be better to focus on a single iteration, and potentially fund the rest after seeing successful results.

I love this project and the team involved. I’m interested in seeing how the project will evolve and reach a wider audience. It’s hard to see any downsides but the proposal could benefit from a clearer articulation of milestones and a more detailed budget justification.

This is a great initiative, but the proposal lacks specifics on how it will deliver on its goals. The plan is too abstract and doesn't include a clear scope of work or a roadmap. Providing details on how the team plans to measure success, as well as specific plans to engage with the colorblind community, would make this proposal much more compelling.

This proposal is really vague. The section titled “Relevant Information Only” is very generic and doesn’t actually explain how the project is a good fit for Nouns. In addition, there are many different aspects to this proposal and I’m unclear how the different elements tie together. The proposal should be broken down into smaller, more focused proposals.

I am concerned that the proposal does not have a clear vision for how this will be a self-sustaining model or how it will grow beyond the initial 12 months. I believe more focus is needed on outlining these plans, which are crucial for ensuring long-term impact.

While the proposal has some cool elements, I think it would be stronger if it included more specifics on how the Nounish Kitpas product will be designed and produced, as well as more examples of the immersive workshop and digital space experiences, to make it more tangible.

The proposal is incredibly ambitious, but lacks focus on establishing a sustainable business model. It would be much more compelling to create a small pilot program, gather feedback, and see if there’s true demand. This would make it much more likely to be successful.

While the project is well-intentioned, I'm unsure how it can truly proliferate Nouns beyond the current communities involved in the proposal. I believe a more concrete plan for how the Nounish Kitpas will be used to attract broader audiences is necessary. For example, I would suggest exploring a partnership with museums and art centers, as well as exploring the potential of creating a virtual gallery to showcase the artwork produced during workshops.

I appreciate the extensive information shared in this proposal, but think there is a need to clarify the unique aspects of this project that differentiates it from other proposals and its alignment with the core values of Nouns.

I am eager to see this proposal come to life and would love to see the interactive coloring book and Farcaster Gallery in action.

This proposal lacks a clear roadmap and the details about the Farcaster integration are vague. I'd suggest focusing on a single workshop location for this initial phase to allow for a tighter focus.

This proposal is a great idea and has the potential to be incredibly impactful, but there is room for improvement, specifically for the proposal to be more focused on the *how* and less on the *why*. The proposal also mentions the importance of onboarding more local artists outside of the Nouns ecosystem and this part could be expanded and developed further.

This proposal is too wide ranging and the scope is quite large. I would suggest breaking the proposal into individual sections that can be voted on independently. This would give the DAO more flexibility to decide which parts are most important and worthy of support.

This proposal outlines a well-planned and ambitious approach to connecting traditional Japanese art with the innovative world of Web3 and NounsDAO. While I believe the proposal could benefit from adding more details about the interactive digital spaces to foster community engagement, the project has the potential to be impactful and worthwhile.

I've been incredibly impressed by the quality of work and the outreach of the previous Kitpas workshops. This will provide an even wider audience to be exposed to both Nouns and this unique art form. I'm also particularly interested in the efforts to create an accessible color tool for individuals with colorblindness.

The proposal is too broad and lacks clear, concise, and defined plans of execution. For instance, it fails to identify any specific schools in the US or provide details on how the Nounish Kitpas will be marketed and distributed, hindering its potential for impact.

This proposal has a great vision but it would be ideal if the proposers would offer to donate some of the Kitpas produced through the project to those who are in need of art supplies. This would further contribute to Nouns' charitable image.

While the proposers have an impressive track record, the proposal lacks a clear strategy for scaling beyond the current scope.

While the proposal is quite ambitious, the team's previous work with Nouns, coupled with their commitment to cultural exchange and inclusivity, makes this a promising project with a strong potential to have a lasting impact.

The proposal embraces and builds upon past work, demonstrating a desire to spread the Nounish ethos through art and culture. This project looks to create positive externalities in a practical and accessible way.

We love the combination of art, inclusivity, and community building. Expanding our reach in new locations like Uganda and creating more opportunities for those with visual impairments aligns with Nouns' values.

A lot of potential with this prop. Love seeing the team push for broader outreach to diverse communities and create lasting connections with global art communities.

This is a great idea and the team has a strong track record, but I'd prefer to see them focus on a smaller, tighter scope project with a clearer path towards results, instead of attempting to execute on this large of an initiative.

It's great that the team is working towards building a self-sustaining model, but the proposal doesn't demonstrate the value to the Nouns community, and the proposed activities feel more like "doing good" than "public goods". The proposal would be stronger if it outlined a clear vision for how Nouns will be involved in the workshops and how the activities will create positive externalities for the community. I suggest the team expand upon the section describing how the Nounish Kitpas materials can be used at future events or integrated into the broader Nouns ecosystem to demonstrate this value.

This prop feels too broad and the goal of 'Nounifying' a pre-existing product like Kitpas feels off. The prop should focus on a specific, clearly defined deliverable instead of attempting to launch a full ecosystem.

The proposal should be more focused on how the project will be replicated to ensure continued growth beyond Japan.

This proposal is focused on creating a new line of Kitpas products, establishing a network of workshops, and developing digital spaces to foster community engagement. It is very long and the plan is quite broad. This is ambitious and feels like it needs more fleshing out to determine if it would be the best use of the Nouns treasury.

This project has a clear goal to improve the world. It's going to make art accessible to people with visual impairments while spreading Nounish culture. I want to see more projects like this from Nouns. It's a win win.

I believe this proposal has the potential to bridge gaps in the Nouns community through artistic expression and reach a wide audience of children. This is a unique opportunity to show how art can be a powerful tool for both local and global communities.

The proposal feels like it's trying to accomplish too much. The scope would be more manageable with a focus on fewer initiatives and could be easily scaled to other regions after a successful launch.

While I appreciate the proposers' enthusiasm, this is still too broad and lacks a clear focus to be compelling. I would suggest a more focused proposal for a single Nounish Kitpas product, or a series of workshops that are more tightly defined, to make a more compelling case for funding.

This is a fantastic idea and I am excited for the team. The proposal is a bit overly ambitious and would benefit from tighter scope. A simple proposal to fund the creation of Kitpas products for an initial run of workshops could be highly impactful. I hope the team iterates and returns with a more focused proposal to support.

This proposal blends physical and digital art in a unique way that could be very impactful and reach a broader audience.

The proposed plan brings together a lot of elements that Nouns has historically supported in the past and provides a strong framework for growth. It’s also a unique opportunity to promote art in an underrepresented area.

This proposal, though well intentioned, is too general in scope and lacking in concrete, measurable deliverables. It could be improved by focusing on a more targeted project with a clear set of goals and metrics for success.

I'm very supportive of the educational aspects of this proposal, especially the emphasis on making the experience accessible to diverse learners, including those with colorblindness.

The project's focus on accessibility and inclusivity aligns well with Nouns' values and I appreciate the inclusion of workshops and the Farcaster Gallery for engagement.

This proposal aligns with the Nouns' commitment to cultural exchange and global community building. The inclusion of accessible tools for visually impaired artists is a commendable addition and deserves recognition. I'm excited to see this program implemented.

While I appreciate the ambitious vision of this proposal, I'd recommend focusing on a single, well-defined area rather than expanding across multiple geographies and initiatives. This would allow for deeper engagement and impact within a more focused scope.

This proposal is well-written, the team is experienced and committed to proliferating Nouns. This project would allow us to spread Nouns to a wider audience through physical goods and workshops and help to create a new generation of creators.

While I believe in the concept and vision here, I think it would be more impactful if this proposal focused on building a community in a single location and then scaling outwards. The current proposal feels too broad and unfocused, especially given the amount of funding requested.

This proposal successfully leverages a successful previous proposal and seeks to expand on that success by focusing on global outreach. By connecting the Nounish art materials and workshops with a broader community, this proposal has the potential to further proliferate Nouns and drive engagement.

I appreciate the proposers' efforts but I believe this project needs more detail and clarity on how it will connect to Nouns. It’s difficult to visualize how these workshops will impact the DAO’s core mission and values given the information provided.

I'm always interested in helping people who are trying to bring Nouns to the world, especially in a way that promotes learning and art. This proposal has a unique approach to spreading Nouns by connecting traditional art with modern technology. I think the scope is narrow enough and their previous track record makes them a good candidate to execute this.

This project feels authentically nounish, and is a great opportunity to build global community engagement with a clear tie to existing efforts. It's especially wonderful that the team has a focus on making creative tools accessible to diverse audiences, including those with visual impairments.

This is a great project to bring Nouns to the world. I love that it uses colorblind friendly tools to benefit a wider group of creators.