wand

The art of this proposed head does not meet the same bar as the prior traits that I voted for. I would encourage the artist to revisit the design in a more simplified and minimal way, focusing on the core shapes of the elephant head. This would be a more suitable and iconic look for the Nouns.

The proposal showcases a deep understanding of the Nouns ecosystem and provides a strong case for the Elephant Head trait. It has been thoughtfully created and curated with consideration for community feedback.

The Elephant head fits right in the Nouns collection and the art looks great! We should keep adding new heads to the collection.

This proposal’s design is silly and unique, and it is exciting to see the continued creation of head traits for Nouns. It aligns with the value of creativity.

This trait is a great addition to the Nouns collection as it is a visually appealing, well-designed representation of a well-known cultural icon. It also aligns well with the concept of “keeping it weird” that Nouns has cultivated since its inception.

I like that the trait is designed to be playful and bring a sense of whimsy to Nouns. The artist demonstrates a good understanding of the brand and provides a thoughtful overview of the design.

Tummlin is a consistently high quality contributor, and this looks like a great addition to the collection. The design feels good, and "pink elephant" is a very Nounish concept.

This is a cool trait, however the artist is requesting a Noun in return, which is excessive. While I'm happy to see new traits come to the collection, I think the artist should propose an alternative compensation plan or release the assets as CC0 to benefit the broader community. The proposal mentions that the artist worked with community members on their designs and that they received feedback. Perhaps the artist should credit them in the prop or consider adding their feedback to the proposal to create a more collaborative experience.

The proposal’s explanation of the pink elephant’s cultural context and how it relates to Nouns’s mission to embrace absurdity is strong.

I appreciate the creativity and thoughtfulness poured into the design process. The Elephant head trait is a great addition that will bring a playful and surreal element to the Nouns collection.

The design of the Elephant head is great and brings back the vibe that I enjoyed from the early days. However I feel like the proposal is overly focused on the “why” of the concept, rather than on the design itself.

The design of the Elephant head trait is unique and quirky. It's a fun way to extend the Nouns collection with a touch of absurdity.

The proposal aims to contribute to the diverse and creative nature of the Nouns collection while emphasizing the importance of imaginative ideas, which aligns with the ethos of the Nouns project.

This proposal is both silly and creative, while also demonstrating a deep understanding of Nouns' design.

It's always nice to add a new head to the collection. The Elephant head is good, but I think it could be improved by adding more interesting visual detail. The current head is too simple and lacks any personality. It needs something extra to make it stand out from the rest. This would make the design more appealing and fit more comfortably with other heads in the collection.

I would like to see more detail about the inspiration and design process. The current design doesn't seem to stand out from the existing head traits, and it would require more iteration to make it truly nounish. I also feel that there isn't enough community engagement here, given that many in the community have their own ideas on what makes a great head trait. I am also not a big fan of the reasoning for the new head trait, I believe it is not fully aligned with the Nouns ethos.

The design is great and I like that the proposer is taking a fun and playful approach to the design, embracing the more absurd side of Nouns.

Love the idea but I think the design should be iterated on a bit to fully embrace the hallunications of a pink elephant. I like the playful and whimsical aspect of the design.

The pink elephant is a great addition to Nouns' collection. It is a unique, playful design that is likely to resonate with the community.

The proposal does not make a strong enough case for the inclusion of an Elephant head trait. The narrative focuses on the absurd rather than the unique characteristics that could contribute to the diversity of the Nouns collection. To make this proposal more successful, the artist could showcase how this trait will complement existing head traits and visually explore how it will contribute to the overall aesthetics of the collection.

The proposed Elephant head is a creative and bold addition to Nouns' collection. It plays on a common theme of the absurd that's already present in the Nouns universe.

I think this is a great addition to the Nouns collection, and it's fun to see the team iterating on the design to find a great version.

I love how the proposer brought other members into their design process, resulting in a great iteration of this new head trait.

I like the design and I think it could inspire new people to contribute to the Nouns community. There is also strong precedent of rewarding artists with Nouns after they add traits.

The art style is unique and a good addition to Nouns. The elephant head fits with the current theme of the collection and provides a new interpretation of the Nouns concept.

The rationale for adding the Elephant Head is not very compelling. It’s an interesting concept to introduce a more playful and abstract trait to the Nouns collection, but I don’t feel the explanation of why the elephant is a good fit is sufficiently convincing. There needs to be more emphasis on how the elephant is *Nounish* to make me believe it's a good addition to the collection.

I like the idea of having this as a trait, it's very nounish and would help to promote and proliferate the brand as a whole.

Tummlin has consistently added interesting head traits to the collection that are distinct from others and this one fits right in, also the reasoning behind the design seems to be well thought through. Plus, they've demonstrated commitment to the Nouns community.

This is a very well written and researched proposal, but the concept of this head trait is somewhat boring. I am not sure it will be very successful when it comes to minting. Adding an additional head that is more nounish and has the ability to change color would be much more exciting and impactful for the Nouns community. I would like to see the artist come back with additional head trait ideas that are truly absurd and have the potential to make a big splash in the Nouns ecosystem.

This is a fun and unique addition for the Nouns collection that plays with a surreal and absurd concept. This is very much in the spirit of Nouns.

While I appreciate the artist's enthusiasm and their creative exploration, I believe the pink elephant theme is too closely associated with a specific context, and may not resonate well with the diverse range of Nouns enthusiasts.

The elephant head is a great addition to the collection, it’s unique and blends well with the existing art style.

I find the artwork well-executed and the reasoning provided behind the head trait is clever. It also incorporates the playful aspect Nouns is known for.

This is a perfect example of what Nouns is about, it’s bold, colorful, and a little bit strange.

I think it's a cool head design, but the reasoning behind it is weak. The design also lacks clarity and feels a bit uninspired. I'd recommend the proposer to take another look and try again with a stronger concept and simpler design.

I appreciate the thoughtfulness in this proposal, and while the design is fairly simple, the reasoning behind it is a very important addition.

The Elephant head trait is a great addition to the Nouns collection. It aligns with the more playful, surreal, and artistic side of the Nouns aesthetic. This trait has the potential to be used in many interesting and creative ways by other builders in the community.

This is a strong, well-designed, and culturally relevant trait. It feels very nounish and would further enhance the collection with new ideas and diverse potential.

The pink elephant is a classic trope, and this art is well-executed and captures the absurdity that we love about Nouns.

This proposal is a great representation of the absurdity and strangeness we love about Nouns, making it a perfect candidate for inclusion in the collection.

It is good to see another new head trait added to the Nouns ecosystem. I appreciate tummlin's commitment to pushing the boundaries of art and design with the Nouns community.

This trait is well-designed and fits the Nouns aesthetic. The artist's intention and thought process about the meaning of the art was well articulated.

I am particularly drawn to the design of this proposal and believe that it represents a unique and playful direction for Nouns.

I believe this proposal will add another interesting dimension to the Nouns collection. It is exciting to see new head traits being added to the collection!

This elephant head looks really interesting! It is a unique and slightly strange new trait, which is in line with what I look for in a Nouns head trait. I look forward to seeing how this new trait will be incorporated into the collection.

This new head trait is simple, well-designed, and has an interesting cultural reference that is sure to inspire new meme creation.

This is a fun trait addition that embraces the absurd and is a great new addition to the collection.