wand

I'm excited to see what comes from this, but the prop feels like it is lacking a clear and concise narrative for the piggy bank. I would suggest focusing on one or two key activations instead of the many outlined, providing specific goals for how the project will proliferate Nouns.

I appreciate the initiative to resubmit a proposal, but this proposal fails to address the concerns I had in the first version. The marketing strategy seems disjointed and a more cohesive plan for outreach would be more effective.

The proposal would benefit from a clearer explanation and roadmap. The budget and timeline seem a bit aggressive, and the team should be prepared to provide more details.

I appreciate the time and effort the team has put into this project, however, I think it is unlikely to be successful and could lead to a more effective proposal.

This proposal was previously voted against because it felt too risky and I am still concerned that the execution is not well defined. I'm interested in exploring ways to use Nouns to support creative endeavors. In this case, I think it would be more impactful to explore smaller scale projects that could be easily replicated in different communities, possibly by using CC0 design files and making the project open source. It would be helpful to see a more detailed plan for the social media strategy, including how the proposers will generate buzz for the project and how they plan to track and measure engagement. More information on the specific events, including how they plan to use the piggy bank, would also be helpful.

The proposal mentions a significant amount of production with 800 piggy banks and has a lack of clarity on how the distribution of these piggy banks will contribute to the Nouns community.

I have previously voted against other proposals for similar types of items - if we are producing a physical item it should have a pre-sale to gauge demand first. I'm happy to vote for this if it gets re-submitted with the pre-sale detail added.

The Nouns Piggy Bank is a fun concept but I think it would be more impactful if the piggy bank was designed with the Noggles in mind. It could also be an effective way to educate children on saving by adding a more interactive component that lets them learn about Nouns and the DAO.

The team has experience with producing high quality work and is demonstrating how they will spread Nouns. However, this proposal would be much stronger if they were to include a plan for community participation. It would be great to see a program where anyone can contribute to the project.

This proposal has a solid plan and aligns with Nouns' efforts to expand beyond the digital realm, making it a good opportunity to engage with the wider community through creative and educational initiatives. The content and the team behind it are also strong.

This proposal has a great opportunity to expand Nouns into a new market and introduce it to a whole new demographic.

This proposal is interesting and has potential but needs further refinement. I am concerned about the lack of a clear pathway to reach a larger audience and the current marketing strategy seems to be too limited. The team has shown competence and passion, but the scope of the project is too broad in its current form. I think a more focused approach with smaller goals would be more successful.

The team has demonstrated successful execution of their pilot program and their project aligns well with Nouns DAO's values. This proposal is an excellent opportunity to increase brand awareness and community engagement.

This proposal needs to be more clearly structured to illustrate the benefits to the DAO. For instance, we need to know how these Piggy Banks will be sold, and what revenue will be returned to the DAO. As it stands, this proposal doesn't provide clear value beyond the community outreach and a brief education about Nouns. There also needs to be more clarity on how the Nouns Piggy Bank will be distributed to influencers.

This proposal is very similar to previous props involving piggy banks that did not garner much community support. The proposal does not offer anything unique and it seems as though the product and the marketing behind it are not well-aligned. I suggest adding a component involving a new art contest on a platform such as Rounds.wtf to generate excitement and potentially inspire the community to participate and create more content that may be used at the gallery or even a larger print run. The new content should be minted on-chain. This approach could help increase the visibility and potential for growth of the Nouns Piggy Bank initiative.

The proposal outlines a clear plan to distribute Nouns Piggy Bank to diverse audiences and emphasizes the educational value and creativity it can foster.

The piggy bank is a fun and accessible way to introduce Nouns to a wider audience. I like that it's designed for a wide range of ages. I'm especially excited about the kids art class component.

This proposal lacks clear and concrete metrics. It's difficult to assess the impact of this project, and needs to be more specific on its intended goals. Also, it's not clear how this can create a unique brand value for Nouns, and might end up simply being a Nouns-branded piggy bank.

I’m a big fan of this team, but I’m just not ready to fund another piggy bank yet. I believe we should focus on creating more unique and high-quality projects rather than funding a product that is already being produced and distributed elsewhere. I'm hoping to see this project evolve as something weirder and more meaningful to Nouns, rather than just another product that’s being marketed. I’d love to see a reimagined, re-imagined version of this proposal that focuses more on the “educational value” and “creative medium” rather than “distribution” and “public events.”

This proposal is a great idea, but the focus on distribution rather than community building makes it more of a marketing ploy. The plan could include a focus on workshops or other engagements to help people understand how the piggy banks are nounish.

This proposal is a great way to continue to grow the Nouns community in a practical and accessible way. The proposal's emphasis on sustainability and creative engagement aligns with the Nouns DAO's core values.

I am confident the piggy bank would be received well by the community, but the proposal lacks enough detail on the distribution strategy. The proposal seems to focus more on the production than spreading and celebrating Nouns.

This proposal is a great attempt to onboard a new audience, but the piggy bank concept feels a bit too broad. To improve it, I suggest narrowing the scope to specific Nouns, like the “Shark, Pickle, Cone” trio, or create limited edition, exclusive designs. I think this would help the piggy bank feel more Nounish.

It's a nice idea and it seems like the proposers have put a lot of effort into building a community around this idea but the proposal could benefit from greater community engagement.

While I appreciate the proposers' efforts, I believe this proposal could be more impactful with a clear focus on introducing the Nouns brand to new communities. There is not enough focus on the Nouns character.

I don't believe the proposal is specific enough about how it will onboard new users to Nouns and am unsure if it will create a lasting impact. I suggest the proposal include details about how it will leverage community events such as meetups in order to attract more users to Nouns.

I think that the proposal is well-intentioned, however, it needs more clarity on how it will be successful beyond simply distributing Nouns Piggy Banks. The proposal could be improved by outlining a more detailed plan for how the piggy banks will be used, including educational materials, interactive activities, and potential partnerships with other organizations focused on financial literacy.

I love seeing Nouns Piggy Banks being distributed and interacting with the community. This proposal is a great step forward for proliferating Nouns in an accessible way.

I enjoyed the educational aspect of the proposal. I would suggest adding more opportunities for collaboration with local artists to personalize the piggy bank and increase engagement for the community.

I appreciate the proposers for the time and effort they put into this proposal but I think it is not quite clear what the Nouns Piggy Bank will be and what its unique value proposition is. The proposed distribution is interesting but could be further improved by outlining a clear and concise explanation for how each activation will benefit the Nouns community and proliferate Nouns.

I appreciate the proposers' hard work in trying to make Nouns Piggy Bank a success, but I believe the proposal could be improved by providing more detail on how the product can actually spread happiness to everyone.

This piggy bank is an excellent way to onboard a wider audience to Nouns. This proposal is well-designed and provides a clear plan for distributing Nouns Piggy Bank to a broad community.

This proposal is a resubmission of a previously rejected proposal with almost identical details and information, which isn't a good sign. I am not a fan of re-submitting old proposals unless there are major changes to the proposal itself.

I think this proposal could benefit from refining its scope and incorporating more Nounish elements into its activation strategies. It also lacks a clear explanation of what makes this Piggy Bank special, and how its distribution will impact the Nouns community.

This proposal lacks a specific outcome or measurement for its success, therefore, it is difficult to assess if it will have any impact for the community. The proposal could be improved by adding quantitative metrics that measure the effectiveness of the Nouns Piggy Bank project in increasing awareness, education, and creativity.

This is a resubmission, which I usually don't support. I'd rather see a new idea presented.

This proposal has the potential to create a fun and engaging experience for the community, encouraging participation in a way that aligns with the Nouns ethos. I am confident this could help broaden the reach of Nouns and make it more accessible to a wider audience.

While I appreciate the community effort and execution of this project so far, the public distribution strategy for the piggy bank feels a bit too scattered and unfocused. I think we could increase the impact by focusing on a single venue for the initial rollout, which would allow us to showcase the project in a more curated and compelling way. For example, a dedicated pop-up store in a high-traffic, kid-friendly area in Makassar, complete with art activities, would maximize reach and visibility.

I appreciate the effort put into the proposal but I think that expanding the "Nouns Piggy Bank" concept beyond a single limited run is required to make it a good fit for Nouns.

I like this idea, but it lacks a solid proposal. I would like to see an updated version with an expanded plan for marketing and distribution. This should also outline how the piggy bank will be used for education, rather than simply existing as a promotional item.

Like the idea of encouraging saving through this fun piggy bank, but the lack of explanation about how these products will be shared, such as how they will be made available to the public and the Nouns community, makes me wary. Also, providing more details about the design iterations would help build more trust in the process.

This proposal does not demonstrate a comprehensive understanding of the Nouns audience, which is comprised of more than just crypto enthusiasts. A broader strategy for engagement is needed.

The proposal is well intentioned and I admire their dedication to the project. However, I'm not entirely convinced that the product will result in real-world impact, and the Nouns Piggy Bank concept could benefit from further development before being distributed to the public. To improve the proposal, I would like to see a more focused marketing strategy that details specific tactics for reaching new audiences and attracting new members to the Nouns ecosystem.

I think this is an incredibly creative way to expand Nouns into the real world and would love to see how it plays out. It also seems to have a lot of local community involvement, which I appreciate. I'm in favor.