wand

I'm excited to see how the creative team embraces the Nouns community and their values, but I feel a musical is a bit too ambitious for Nouns at this stage. I would suggest narrowing the scope and starting with a smaller project, like a single song or animation, to validate the concept and build a stronger understanding of the community's preferences.

A musical can be a great addition to the Nouns ecosystem, but this proposal doesn’t take into consideration other avenues to reach wider audiences beyond a traditional broadway production. It would be great to see them explore more creative and contemporary avenues, such as online releases or immersive NFT experiences.

The proposal is well-written, detailed and outlines a clear path towards production. The team has a lot of experience in the field and I believe that they can successfully produce a high quality Nouns musical.

This musical has the potential to reach a wide audience and be a compelling addition to the Nouns universe. The team behind it seems dedicated and passionate about bringing this project to life, and I appreciate them for their commitment to the community.

This proposal seems ambitious and exciting, but it lacks details on how Nouns will be involved in the production. It also needs a more concise breakdown of how funds will be used, and how they'll be used to proliferate Nouns. I recommend a more detailed breakdown of the various production phases, including the expected deliverables.

The proposal provides a clear roadmap for the project, which details how this musical can bring a new audience to Nouns. The musical synopsis demonstrates how the story can be impactful and provide a unique perspective on the Nouns universe.

I like the concept of a Nouns Musical but I am not sure if this is the right team for Nouns to bet on. Specifically, I’m not sure if they fully understand the brand and what Nouns values. I would like to see more tangible proof of work, particularly related to onchain collaborations, as well as a deeper exploration of the Nouns brand within the story and music.

This project has the potential to showcase Nouns in an artistic and engaging way, connecting the community with broader audiences and building a valuable asset for the Nouns brand.

I'm excited about the prospect of a Nouns musical, but I think the proposal could be improved by providing a more concrete roadmap for the development of the script and production process. I also think the proposed budget is too high for the initial stages.

I'm impressed by the proposers' dedication to the project and the vision they have for a Nouns musical. The inclusion of a song and a brief synopsis is helpful to see how the story is developing. I believe this project has the potential to be impactful and generate excitement within the community.

I'm concerned that the proposal lacks a clear road map beyond the initial script writing phase, and that its focus on a specific director is too narrow. The proposal could be improved by outlining the broader plan for theatrical production and showcasing the strengths of the artistic team in greater detail.

I'm very impressed with how much work has been put into this proposal already, and I'm confident that a full musical would be a great addition to the Nouns ecosystem.

This proposal is a great example of how Web3 can be used to support creative projects. I would be interested in seeing this musical come to life.

I like this proposal. However, I'm not a fan of the concept's reliance on a pre-existing narrative that involves the characters' relationship with the machine that generates them. The music and story have potential, but the narrative could benefit from a more open-ended approach that allows the characters to develop organically and express themselves outside of their creator's constraints.

I am not confident in the ability for this proposal to fulfill its objectives given the timeframe requested. The proposed timeline doesn't provide enough time to successfully complete such an ambitious endeavor and a more realistic scope is required.

This proposal demonstrates a clear understanding of the Nouns community and its potential, and outlines a detailed and ambitious plan for the development of an original musical.

I’m not a fan of the time frame outlined in this proposal. It’s too ambitious and lacks a concrete strategy for marketing and distribution, which is critical for the success of any musical production.

While I’m intrigued by the concept, I’m not yet convinced by the direction of the story. Additionally, I think the proposal would benefit from a more specific narrative or vision for how the project will unfold.

The proposal does not detail how they plan to ensure that this musical resonates with a wide audience. I would like to see a concrete strategy for reaching a wider audience, including potential partners or distribution channels.

I am very impressed with the team and the scope of this project. However, the proposal needs to provide greater detail on the potential impact and reach, beyond just showcasing the project.

While this is a fun idea, I appreciate the work that the proposers have done but I think a more focused approach might be more successful at this stage. I would like to see a leaner version of this proposal that focuses on the most important parts of the development process.

While I love the concept, I’m not convinced that the team has established a strong enough connection with the Nouns community. It is a very ambitious project and I believe that a proposal showcasing a more complete, multi-faceted vision would be much more impactful.

I’m supportive of projects that are ambitious and creative but I need more information to be able to support a project like this. The project summary is extremely vague with little details about the scope and scale of the project. Providing more specific information about the events the project will produce would be helpful.

I'm not convinced that this is a good use of Nouns funds and would prefer to see the musical go through another phase before I approve it.

This prop is trying to do too much in one go. I would prefer to see them break it up into multiple props, with an initial focus on just the script and a single song.

I really enjoy the previous work from the team in Gnars and believe they can easily deliver this prop with a high level of quality. I'm very excited and would love to introduce some versatile wheelchairs to promote inclusivity.

I appreciate the effort but I think the budget is too high and the DAO would be better suited to fund smaller projects or those that are further along. I think the proposers could improve their chances of getting their proposal funded by reducing their requested budget and highlighting their connections to industry professionals.

While I love the idea of a Nouns Musical, I am concerned that the scope of this proposal is not focused enough. The proposers need to work on identifying a single deliverable for the first phase of this project. This will help to ensure that the team is laser-focused on achieving a singular goal and delivering a high-quality product within the first phase.

It’s an ambitious project with a lot of potential but needs to be developed further, perhaps with a shortened timeline and more realistic goals. The community would also be more receptive with a proof of concept before a full production budget.

While I find the ambition of the proposal refreshing, I believe it's best to break it down into smaller, more manageable phases with interim deliverables and community feedback. This will help ensure alignment between the project's vision and the DAO's interests, ultimately leading to greater success.

This proposal seems extremely ambitious in its scope and timeline. It’s difficult to understand the production process and how it benefits the Nouns community beyond simply creating a musical.

This proposal lacks a concrete plan, especially around production and marketing. It's great to see the passion behind the project, but there needs to be more clarity about how these funds will be used and how the community can directly contribute to the success of the musical.

We have to see this musical come to life, Nouns can definitely be more than just a meme coin! This proposal is a great step towards bringing more exposure to Nouns and a better understanding of what we stand for.

I appreciate the ambition of this proposal, but it needs some clarifying details. I'd like to see a clearer breakdown of the requested funding, how it will be used, and what the expected deliverables are in terms of the script and other elements. I also wonder if the proposal could elaborate on how it will address the potential challenges of translating a unique web3 project like Nouns into a widely accessible format.

This proposal has potential to further grow the Nouns community with greater exposure to a broad audience, especially those outside of Web3.

The proposal is too broad and lacks a clear scope. I'd prefer a more focused project, such as funding just the script or the album, and potentially the play itself in a later stage. I also feel this is a bit too early to be thinking about a Broadway show.

The ambition of this project is exciting, I believe this musical will be incredibly well received by the Nouns community and the wider public.

The proposal is highly detailed and demonstrates the experience of the proposers in the music industry. This project has a strong potential to create positive impact and reach a wide audience for Nouns, and it has a clear path to execution.

This musical, although a great idea, needs more to connect with the broader community. Consider exploring ways to open source the musical or to have it be part of other events like NounsFest to ensure more direct community involvement.

This proposal is lacking specifics on the marketing plan and the team members contributing to the production. It is not clear how the DAO will benefit from this musical or how the proposers will utilize the budget.

The production plan is a little too vague and the community needs more clarity on the timeline for the next steps and how the project will benefit Nouns.

The proposal is too vague and lacks concrete plans for reaching a wide audience and generating a return on investment. While the description of the musical seems promising, it needs to provide more clarity and detail on the specific steps to bring the project to life.

I am excited to see a Nouns-themed musical come to life. This proposal is a great step towards making that happen, and I am confident in the team's ability to deliver a quality product.

I believe that this project has the potential to introduce a new and unique audience to Nouns, and I am excited to see how this project evolves.