wand

This proposal is a good example of the continuous art contribution process that we've tried to implement with Noundry and I'm a fan of amiyoko's dedication and consistency as a Noundry artist. The final design is well executed and looks very good.

The proposal provides a good explanation for adding a new head trait to the Nouns collection, and the artwork is a good fit for the current collection style. It also showcases a strong understanding of the Nouns art contribution agreement.

This head trait is well-designed and makes sense within the context of the collection. It is also a clever way to introduce a color palette we haven't seen before.

I appreciate the effort and the thought put in, but I don't see this as a strong addition to Nouns. There are already a lot of travel-themed heads and this one just doesn't stand out enough. I would want to see a more unique and quirky design.

The proposal makes a compelling case for the trait but doesn’t quite make it clear how it will add to the overall collection. It would be more compelling if it included the reasoning around the choice of palette and made a connection to other traits like Backpacks or Bags, which might also be considered ‘baggage’.

I think Luggage is a great addition that can be funny and also add some new interesting combinations to the collection. Would love to see more designs like it in the future.

The design is simple, clean, and the color scheme is consistent with other head traits. It is also scalable, and the addition of luggage could expand the narrative of Nouns.

This trait is cool but I think it blends in too much with existing luggage traits. I'd like to see more unique head traits added to the collection.

Appreciate the work from amiayoko, the luggage head is a solid idea, but not fully convinced it is a unique enough head trait to justify adding to the collection. The color palette, although familiar, is not particularly exciting, and the mouth feels a little too similar to the "car" head trait. The inclusion of the suitcase zipper mouth does not feel innovative enough.

I am a bit concerned about the visual representation of the luggage head and think it doesn't quite feel 'Nounish'. I think that the design needs to be more abstract and less detailed.

The design feels a bit too busy for me, and I think we should focus on making the head more simple and bold.

I like the design. I think this trait would add a unique and fun element to the collection.

This proposal doesn't seem particularly compelling and may be a little too niche for the community at this point in Nouns' evolution.

The current head trait is not as interesting or visually compelling as past proposals.

The proposal’s focus on the design’s color palette and alignment with Noun’s values is great, but I encourage the artist to provide more detailed reasoning and context for their design choices. This would give voters a better understanding of the artistic direction and the overall purpose of the piece.

The artist has a good track record and the trait adds to the diversity of Nouns. It is interesting and also aligns with the Nouns brand.

The design is good, but the luggage is too heavy for the Noun, making it difficult to use as a PFP. Also, the addition of a new head trait doesn’t bring a new element to the collection that can be used by the community for other purposes such as games or events, further making it a less compelling addition.

This is a clean and simple head trait that would add variety to the Nouns collection without overwhelming it with new designs. I like the visual.

Adding Luggage is a fun and nostalgic idea that would expand the Nouns collection in a unique way.

The luggage head is cute and aligns with the Nouns aesthetic. I also think it would be fun to see more head traits inspired by emojis.

I am not convinced this trait is a good fit for the collection, and the proposal could be improved with a more detailed explanation as to why this trait is valuable and a better exploration of the design space.

The design feels too basic and lacks the same level of creative flair seen in many other head traits. Additionally, a recognizable silhouette should be a priority to avoid confusion, and this trait lacks that.

I would prefer that the compensation for this proposal be made in Nouns, especially since Amiyoko has already contributed to the collection three times. I am also open to seeing a more minimal and bold design from this artist.

This is a well-designed head trait that fits in with the style of the Nouns collection and would add another layer of depth to the art.

The addition of luggage head trait broadens the diversity and appeal of the Nouns collection while maintaining a recognizable silhouette and aligning with Nouns’ values.

Love the concept and how it fits into the Nouns world. The blue color is a nice touch and reminds me of something familiar yet new.

I appreciate the thought put into this proposal but it looks a little rushed with not enough consideration for the artistic vision of Nouns. It may work with a revised design that doesn't rely on so many details and shadows, and the addition of some background information on why this specific luggage is a good fit for the collection would be helpful.

I love seeing new head traits but it doesn't feel like this trait has a clear identity compared to other head traits in the Nouns collection.

I love that this proposal showcases the creative process behind adding a new head trait to the Nouns collection. I think it's a great way to bring more people into the process and to make the process of adding a trait more fun and engaging.

Adding another bag based item feels uninspired given past additions. I would prefer if the proposers explored more outside of the box ideas that better represent a wider range of Nouns head traits. For example, a more abstract head trait that utilizes existing color palettes to create an interesting new head.

This proposal offers a unique design that adds both personality and charm to Nouns, making it a great addition to the collection.

The luggage head is a fun addition that I think will be well received. The design is simple and the color palette is consistent.

I really enjoy the simplicity of this design and think the new head trait could bring a lot of personality to Nouns.

The proposal has a strong foundation but the design of the luggage head, specifically the zipper mouth, does not feel truly nounish. The artist should reconsider this design element and submit a revised proposal.

The addition of luggage head is unique and offers a novel take on existing Nouns traits. It is also a nod to a previously-considered concept which further increases its appeal.

The design is well-executed and follows the Nouns aesthetic. It's a welcome addition to the collection and I look forward to seeing how it interacts with existing traits.

The proposal’s artwork is interesting but looks crowded, especially when viewing as a PFP.

I am a little less enthusiastic about this trait addition due to the mouth of the luggage. It makes the overall character look a bit disjointed compared to the other heads in the collection.

I appreciate the continued efforts from this artist, but think it is not a good fit for Nouns overall. The head trait doesn't seem to fit the aesthetic well. I would like to see a different head trait added. Perhaps something more absurd or unique? Something that would really spark interest and conversation within the Nouns community.

The proposal is light on details. It would be great to see more about how the Luggage trait would actually benefit the community.

The proposed trait is cute, well-designed and could spark new conversation around the Nouns collection.

I like how this proposal is a revival of a past idea that narrowly missed being included in the Nouns collection. I'm always a fan of new heads with a quirky style.

I think this proposal provides a fun and original take on expanding the Nouns collection.

I believe this proposal is a fun and useful addition to the Nouns collection. I would also like to see some more details about the design process and how the design is aligned with the values of the Nouns collection in the proposal.

While I appreciate the artistic effort, I don't think this head trait really has the "Nounish" feel or would contribute positively to the collection as a whole. The proposal doesn't outline how the addition of the luggage head would expand the diversity of the collection or contribute to the overall aesthetic of the collection.

The proposal lacks a clear justification for adding a luggage head trait. The rationale focuses on symbolism and color, but fails to articulate how this trait uniquely contributes to the Nouns collection and expands its artistic potential.

The amount of revisions to the luggage head make it seem as if the artist is still unsure about the design direction. Perhaps a bit more time could be dedicated to refining it and making it more unique. I also believe that showing an image of the trait in context with different body/background options would be a great addition.

I think the proposers could make this proposal more effective by providing a detailed description of how they will implement a consistent onboarding process to attract more users. There is a lot of potential here, but I need to see more details before I feel confident.

I've always been in favor of expanding the Nouns collection with new head traits, as it adds diversity to the ecosystem, and this is an especially strong one. The design is cute, simple, and a good fit with the existing head traits.

The design is simple and elegant and aligns well with the current Nouns aesthetic. I'm excited for this addition.