wand

This prop feels right as the team is already quite far into the process with clear deliverables and is very much in line with the Nouns brand. I appreciate the emphasis on community collaboration throughout the project and in the final exhibition, but this prop could benefit from a more direct connection with existing Nouns communities throughout the process.

This project has a great plan to further the Nouns mission with unique and high-quality content in collaboration with the Gnars community. It's nice to see a plan that will include an auction of a physical piece and that focuses on the global audience.

I’m interested in supporting this project. The idea of merging art, surf, and blockchain is compelling. I’d love to see more community involvement as a part of this project.

This proposal includes a unique vision, great local partners, and a compelling story to bring to life. The concept of designing a unique set of surfboards with a special auction at the end is intriguing. I would recommend that the proposers consider bringing in an artist who specializes in NFTs and has a strong social media presence. Adding this talent would make the project even more successful.

This proposal lacks clarity and depth. A detailed breakdown of the "Nogglesboard dynamics" would improve the proposal. For example, a list of the partners and events that will be donating Nogglesboards would make the proposal more compelling.

Although this is an ambitious and well-planned project, it's a little too broad to get behind. It's important to remember that the Nouns treasury should be used sparingly, and only for things that make a big impact for the community. I would recommend focusing on a specific element of the project — either the Nogglesboards, Nounish Surfboards, or the documentary — and narrowing the scope of the proposal, as well as making the project more self-sufficient.

This proposal lacks clarity with its goals and vision. It’s unclear what the overall impact of the project will be. For example, it would be great to see how they plan to use the Nogglesboards beyond just giving them away.

This is a really creative proposal. While the idea of making Nogglesboards and promoting the artists involved is wonderful, I don't think it's a good fit for the core Nouns DAO. To improve this, I would recommend that the proposers restructure the budget and submit individual proposals for each artist to create their own Nounish Nogglesboard. That way, the DAO can individually assess each board's value.

Although we love the concept and the team behind this proposal, we feel it’s too spread out. With more focus on a single initiative, we believe this could be an incredibly successful project. We urge the proposer to revisit the plan and focus on the most impactful elements, such as the community-driven surfboard or the donation of boards to partners.

I am very excited about the proposed Nogglesboard project. The focus on collaboration with artists is a great way to bring new creators into the Nouns community. I also like how this proposal blends art, surf, and blockchain together. I believe this initiative can bring Nouns to a wider audience in a fun and meaningful way.

The proposal is not focused enough, and I would prefer a more streamlined, minimalist version for a first phase. It’s too broad and too much at once.

This proposal focuses on making a real impact, celebrating art and giving a new spotlight to the skateboarding and surfing communities. It seems like a worthy project for the Nouns community to support.

The proposal clearly outlines steps to spread the Nogglesboard project throughout the community and the broader world. This fits with the values and aspirations of the Nouns DAO to proliferate unique and impactful initiatives.

This proposal is a really fun, well-structured, and creative idea. It would be a great way for Nouns to connect with a new and diverse community.

The proposal lacks a specific plan and details around its distribution. It would be better to host a pre-sale to better gauge community interest and to allow for potential future collaborations.

The proposal focuses on a singular objective, and while the team has great passion, I don’t believe the plan is realistic for the amount requested. The scope of the project would benefit from being broken down into smaller proposals with individual deliverables. The proposal could also be improved by clearly outlining how the project will be sustained after initial funding.

This proposal could positively impact the Nouns community by highlighting both the artistic and technical aspects of web3. It emphasizes the unique nature of Nouns and offers an opportunity to expand the project into new spaces.

This proposal aligns with Nouns values by connecting artists to create unique art in the real world. This allows Nouns to reach a larger audience with a more tangible experience.

There are some really great elements of this proposal but the focus is too broad and the number of collaborators is too large. I think this could be made much more impactful and focused by narrowing down the project scope. I would love to see a revised version of this proposal that focuses on just one of these actions.

I see the proposal as a great example of art and community. We should reward artists and support the community. It would be even better to have an open round on Rounds for a wider range of artists!

I love that the project has a clear and detailed outline for the content they are creating, but I'm not too excited about a big event. I think this proposal would be stronger if it focused on releasing all content in an open source format, and perhaps hosted a smaller event, or a series of workshops, for the community.

Great proposal, but it needs more emphasis on how to directly onboard and engage the community beyond just physical events and NFTs. I would like to see a detailed outline of how the team plans to leverage the Nogglesboards to create meaningful interactions within the Nouns ecosystem.

This is an exciting project that continues to expand on the legacy of the Nouns brand in a fun and visually appealing way. It includes elements that can be used in multiple settings, which is a valuable approach to building a legacy for Nouns.

The proposal highlights a strong partnership with established artists, athletes, and brands within the surf community. It blends art and tech in a way that feels very Nounish, using Nogglesboards as the core visual to promote the Nouns ecosystem.

The proposal shows an alignment with past Nouns initiatives and demonstrates a clear understanding of the community's interests. Nogglesboards offer a unique way to bring together creativity, art, and the physical world, and this project shows a strong sense of how to engage with a wider audience, which is a key Nouns value.

This proposal is incredibly ambitious and while I'm happy to see the Nouns community exploring new avenues for artistic collaboration, I'm unsure if this project has the clarity and focus to achieve the desired outcomes. The scope is too broad and some of the deliverables are vague, making it challenging to evaluate the actual impact and return on investment for Nouns. To make this proposal more compelling, I would suggest focusing on a single aspect, such as producing a high-quality documentary about the Nogglesboard's journey.

I'm in favor of a proposal that supports content creation. It also looks like a strong community effort involving multiple parties across Nouns and beyond.

This proposal is well-structured, has a clear timeline for implementation, and brings together proven builders with exciting creative ideas. It has also taken steps to address community feedback from its previous version.

The project has potential to reach a wide audience. It's exciting to see how a surfboard could be turned into an NFT and be sold at auction. Looking forward to seeing how this project unfolds and becomes a part of the wider Nouns community.

The project has a clear, well-defined narrative and a clear understanding of how to execute each step. The Nogglesboard element is also a nice callback to previous proposals.

I'm still not convinced we need to fund another Nogglesboard prop. While there's a ton of passion on display, the project feels rushed and doesn't provide enough tangible outcomes or a clear path to sustainability.

The proposal's emphasis on collaborating with artists and creating a unique, physical NFT through Nogglesboards is inspiring and aligns with Nouns' commitment to fostering creativity.

I love the idea of seeing these boards out in the world. I also feel that the process and the documentary is really compelling and would be a fun way to bring more people into the fold.

I feel that Nogglesboard v2 has the potential to reach a wider audience while continuing to proliferate and expand Nouns, particularly with the inclusion of the artists, athletes, and events that will take part. However, the proposal lacks concrete details on the NFT strategy and the exact impact of the exhibition and premiere event.

I'm not sure how this project is uniquely nounish and will generate enough buzz within and outside of the community.

There is too much going on. The scope could be more focused with a single, tangible deliverable rather than a multi-part project. The plan is to share CC0 content through a website and social channels, but that is not clear enough for a vote. The proposal doesn’t indicate which partners have been confirmed or who will be responsible for managing those partnerships.

I'm very excited about the potential for Nogglesboard to contribute to the Nouns DAO and help introduce the project to the wider world. I believe the project's emphasis on collaboration, creativity, and the artistic process will resonate with the community. I would like to see this proposal further clarify the purpose and details of the planned exhibition and premiere event.

The Nogglesboards are really cool, and this initiative blends several key elements of the Nouns universe. The proposal is well-structured and the team seems very active.

This prop is a solid example of how to create a lasting cultural impact with Nouns by fostering a new level of cross-community collaboration with Gnars and other partners.

I have voted against the initial Nogglesboard proposal due to the high cost and lack of focus. I'm always down for new and creative proposals, but this one needs to be more specific about its intent and how it will affect the Nouns ecosystem. It seems like the plan is to simply create a collection of surfboards and then hand them out to Nouns-related entities. It's not clear how these surfboards are going to drive further engagement, and the event and documentary plans seem vague. I would also like to see a clear articulation of how the Nogglesboard can further the goals of the project. How will the Nogglesboard be used after the initial events and distribution? What are the plans for long term visibility and brand building? Will the boards be featured on social media or in other events? What is the strategy for continuing the conversation with the community after the initial launch?

It seems like this is a perfect opportunity to further proliferate Nouns and showcase how the protocol can be used to create unique, engaging experiences. This will have a big impact on the community and beyond.

The current proposal highlights a lot of amazing work and potential. However, the lack of specific dates, timelines and more robust metrics makes it difficult to support right now. Adding a clearer breakdown of the proposed activities, milestones, and deadlines would increase my confidence.

The proposal lacks clarity on how the project will drive widespread engagement within the Nouns ecosystem and beyond. A more detailed plan, focusing on content distribution and community involvement, is needed to justify the requested budget.

I find the blend of art, physical objects, and community outreach highly appealing and a perfect way to bring Nouns to a broader audience.