wand

This proposal focuses on a digital-first approach, which I think is a good strategy for Nouns at this moment in time and I appreciate how it allows us to take an iterative approach to the project.

This project embraces the art of Nouns in a more tangible way by showcasing the artistry of the Nouns. It is a very creative approach to building on Nouns. However, the proposal could be improved by adding more examples of the planned content for the website.

The proposal was initially too expensive and the addition of 3D printing wasn't something I was in favor of, however, by focusing solely on the digital, I think this is a great project with a lot of potential.

This proposal is exciting but lacks a more concrete plan for future initiatives that can be implemented. The proposal doesn't offer enough concrete goals to justify continued funding beyond the initial website.

I would love to see a website that includes video and audio content in addition to text. This is a missed opportunity to create a really cool experience.

This proposal has the potential to reach a wide audience, create a new way for people to view Nouns, and add a new storytelling vertical to the ecosystem.

This proposal is well-structured and outlines a clear pathway to success. It's exciting to see a digital first approach that expands the story of Nouns art in a way that is easy to access and consume.

The content and vision of the proposal are strong and I appreciate the proposer for continually trying to improve the project. The proposer clearly understands the value of a digital-first approach and the commitment to creating an open-source project is a great sign.

This project will build upon a strong foundation of existing Nouns art while also focusing on a digital first strategy. The reduced budget and scaled back project timeline will help ensure that resources are not being wasted.

A strong team of builders with a well-defined scope and a proven track record for creating high-quality content within the Nouns ecosystem. Would love to see this vision brought to life.

Facu, i love the general idea but the writing is a bit light on details and context and doesnt fully convince me that it's the best use of NounsDAO funds. I'd like to see more details about the content (especially what makes it different from the existing 'Art of Nouns' material) and a clear explanation of how this project will be promoted and the expected reach. I also think the art book could be a separate proposal, once a larger audience can engage with the website and the scope is clearer.

I am a big believer in Nouns art and think this project will create valuable new content for our community. This is a great step towards showcasing the work of our artists in new ways.

I like this proposal's approach of focusing on creating high-quality, digital-first content to tell the story of Nouns art. It's a smart and efficient way to showcase this new perspective without incurring unnecessary costs.

This is an interesting concept and a new way for Nouns to proliferate. It's exciting to see what the future holds.

This proposal has a great idea that could really help grow the Nouns ecosystem, but it's missing a specific plan for community involvement to really make it a long-term success.

I am a big supporter of proposals that introduce more people to Nouns and art. The digital-first approach is a good plan to keep costs down and test demand. It also seems like the proposers have experience in the field, having built within the Nouns ecosystem before.

While this proposal is intriguing and I appreciate the proposers’ efforts to reduce the budget, the project is not fully fleshed out and the deliverables are not convincing enough.

It's great to see the proposers embracing digital-first and streamlining the initial project. This will allow for quicker iteration and valuable learning. Aligning with the ethos of 'weird over boring,' I'd love to see the team expand on their vision with interactive content, potentially through gamification of the website.

The digital first approach makes sense, and I appreciate the scaling back of the budget. BUT I believe that the focus should be on exploring content to inspire artists and create the space for them to create their own nounish art -- I think the website should be a launchpad for that. Also, I think that a short series of videos exploring the history of Nouns and the artists that have been involved would be a great way to further inspire artists and show the incredible work that has been done by the community.

Facu is extremely nounish, and his work on this project has been really impressive. I think this digital-first strategy will allow for an easy and intuitive way to share the story of Nouns in a beautiful way. I can't wait to see what comes next.

This proposal is focused on a digital-first approach which is a wise choice in my opinion, but the proposal would benefit from clearly defining the purpose of the website in greater detail. The current outline does not provide enough substance.

This is a great opportunity to further develop Nouns and its art. The proposal is thoughtful and well-written.

I think it's great to see Facu adjust the proposal to address feedback and the current state of the DAO. It’s a great example of what NounsDAO can achieve: a dedicated art studio focused on the Nouns collection.

This revised version of the proposal emphasizes a digital-first approach, making it more efficient and less risky, particularly for the DAO. This makes the proposal more compelling given the reduced budget and less emphasis on physical aspects.

I'm always excited to see Nouns expanding its reach and adding new perspectives on how it can be valued. This proposal leverages art in a unique way and could introduce a new audience to the Nouniverse.

This proposal expands the reach of Nouns and is a great way to attract a new audience.

This proposal presents a well-defined vision and clearly demonstrates the value this project could bring to the Nouns ecosystem. The digital-first approach, with its focus on accessibility, creativity, and continuous improvement, makes it a compelling proposition.

The proposal is well thought out, but the vision for the project lacks specifics about how we will cultivate the community and encourage those outside of the Nouns ecosystem to engage with the project. I believe that by establishing a more concrete vision of what comes after the website and book, we can ensure that this initiative is truly impactful and can continue to benefit the community.

The revised proposal's focus on digital-first delivery is more efficient and aligns with the feedback from the community.

I believe the project has the ability to attract a new type of collector and reach a new audience interested in art and design. The digital-first approach is the best way to start and reduces risk to the DAO.

The proposal is lacking a clear focus on the "why" behind the project's objectives and needs more specific details on the storytelling. It could be improved with a clear definition of how it will be different from existing Nouns resources and what value it will bring to the community.

Love the digital-first approach, making it easy for everyone to access the content. I'm excited to see what Facu's team will create, and I'm looking forward to the book.

This proposal is missing a clear vision for what comes next and feels very similar to other existing proposals. While there are many good ideas, this proposal feels lacking in the depth and breadth I've seen from successful past projects. For instance, more details around specific ideas for a future social media campaign, IRL events, or exhibitions would add much-needed context. I would be more inclined to vote 'for' if these aspects were further developed.

This proposal is a strong digital-first approach, a better use of resources and a smart way to evolve the collection.

The proposed project is well-aligned with the value of creating high-quality digital art. The proposed website and art book are a perfect way to expand the lore of Nouns and introduce new audiences to the ecosystem. The project would also benefit from being distributed via Nouns' social media accounts and including more video content.

I believe this proposal to explore Nouns as art is a valuable and unique direction. The proposed website will allow for much needed creative storytelling to increase interest in Nouns both within the DAO and with new audiences.

This is the perfect step for Nouns to create a more engaging and curated experience. The proposal’s content creation can spark a deeper understanding and appreciation for the art that powers Nouns.

While I like the idea, I think this proposal is over-reliant on an already successful project, making it unclear if this project has true potential for growth or is just a stepping stone.

I appreciate this revised proposal and the reduced ask. I do think there should be a dedicated section focused on the art and artists within Nouns to enhance this proposal. Providing more context and details on who made the art will be valuable to the project’s goals.

I appreciate the proposers taking in feedback from their previous proposal. I think the digital-first approach is the right way to go about this, but would suggest including a marketing campaign to help broaden awareness of the project.

I appreciate the team's effort and the revised vision for this project, but I'm still hesitant to support this proposal in its current state. I find that the project lacks a clear sense of how it will contribute to the Nouns community beyond simply showcasing the artwork. While the website is a strong first step, I would prefer to see a more detailed vision for how this proposal will evolve beyond this initial phase, with a plan for a more tangible connection to the wider Nouns ecosystem. Additionally, the website's scope could be expanded to feature more interactive elements that actively engage users, such as a digital gallery or a curated timeline of the Nouns' visual history.

The proposal is well-written and provides a clear vision for the Nouns project. The digital-first approach also reduces risk and aligns with the community's feedback on similar proposals.

This proposal is an excellent example of how to adapt and improve a previous proposal while still upholding the project’s core vision. It is well-organized and includes clear goals, a well-defined timeline, and a well-researched plan to showcase the art of Nouns in an engaging way.

I would like to see the proposal focus more on onboarding new users to the Nouns ecosystem and highlight the utility of NFTs in this context. Additionally, I think it would be better if the content was released as a series of Open Editions rather than just a single mint. This would provide more flexibility in the form of potential distribution and reward mechanisms as well as give more opportunities for community engagement. This is also a chance to really dive into the culture and history of Nouns. For example, we should be celebrating the founding of the different DAO's and the artists who made them special. We should be showcasing the power of the DAO model, the history of the NFT space, and the beauty of Nouns culture. I would like to see that happen in the form of a mini-series or a multi-part digital zine.

I am very interested in the idea of showcasing Nouns art in a more refined way. With a digital-first approach, it will be easier to iterate and refine the project. I think the website will be successful.

I like how this prop continues to push the boundary of what nouns can be and to explore how the art can be expanded.

I am unsure about the long-term impact of this project. It is great that the proposal team is rethinking the project, but I would like to see more details regarding a specific plan to move from the digital-first approach to a future physical component of the project.

This proposal is lacking a clear plan for engaging with the community and attracting new artists and creators. The proposal also lacks a strong and detailed strategy for distributing the content to a wider audience, and I would prefer to see more focus on specific plans for marketing and promotion. I appreciate the vision of this project, but it would be more impactful with more detailed plans for distribution, community outreach, and collaboration.

I like the updated vision and direction. I hope this project will give us the chance to attract a new audience and showcase Nouns in new ways.