wand

This proposal is too heavily focused on NOGS, and while I support its growth, I believe the DAO should fund projects that provide a broader benefit to the Nouns ecosystem.

The proposed mandate for a full year, although well-intentioned, feels a bit too ambitious given the recent discourse around treasury and the current market climate. Instead, I'd like to see a shorter term with a focus on the white-label platform for broader ecosystem adoption, and Noggles Club v.1 as a pilot. We can always revisit funding for the full year if the DAO sees significant traction with this smaller initial investment. This would give time to gauge adoption and ensure the project's long-term viability.

While I appreciate the passion, the proposal doesn't clearly illustrate how the budget will be used to help the DAO and the community. More specific examples should be included on how the money will be used to bring value to the community. I also am not convinced that the language used about memecoin should be so casual, and a more professional tone should be adopted.

The proposal could be improved by focusing on a more targeted approach to community and content efforts rather than spreading resources across multiple channels, given the limited budget. This would help with better coordination, engagement, and stronger community building.

NNS Labs has demonstrated a track record of success with its previous mandates, and this proposal offers a well-defined roadmap for continued growth and development. Its focus on increasing recurring revenues and expanding NNS capabilities will positively impact the Nouns ecosystem.

I believe this proposal can contribute to a more diverse set of income streams and create an infrastructure that is more resistant to change over time.

The proposal feels a bit rushed. I'd like to see more of NNS Labs' work and engagement with the community prior to a large fund allocation. I would also like to see more detailed explanations of the products in the proposal, including examples of how each will contribute to the ecosystem.

NNS Labs has a proven track record of success and delivers a strong value proposition. The community is well-positioned to benefit from continued development.

This revised proposal shows a strong commitment to both completing its vision and ensuring it reaches self-sustainability within a year. We commend NNS Labs for absorbing the reduction internally and providing even greater value in return.

NNS Labs has consistently delivered on its promises in the previous mandates, and its focus on community engagement and onboarding aligns with the Nouns ecosystem’s goals.

This proposal seems like a good fit for Nouns but I'm not a fan of the narrative and the general lack of emphasis on community engagement. The proposers could benefit from crafting a more targeted approach that focuses on the unique contributions of NNS Labs. Maybe instead of a general overview of what each project does, the proposers could focus on outlining the core milestones or specific value propositions that would be delivered over the next 12 months.

NNS Labs has demonstrated a strong track record in developing products that benefit the Nouns ecosystem. This updated proposal with a reduced budget is well-aligned with the DAO's core values.

NNS Labs provides constant innovation and has already demonstrated an ability to drive the Nouns ecosystem through the various products they have created. I think it's important to continue to support them as they move forward.

NNS Labs is a well-established and valuable part of the Nouns ecosystem. I appreciate that the proposers were open to feedback from the community and adjusted the scope to better align with the community's needs. I'm looking forward to seeing what they accomplish in this next mandate.

This proposal has a clear vision and an impressive track record of previous deliveries, which could contribute to the DAO's long term success.

NNS Labs is a proven and reliable partner for the DAO. The proposal outlines a clear roadmap for the development of NOGS and NNS while also emphasizing the importance of community engagement. The team’s commitment to openness and adaptability is reassuring.

This proposal has proven to be impactful in the past, and the reduced budget request shows a commitment to fiscal responsibility. NNS Labs is essential to the growth of the Nouns ecosystem.

NNS Labs has already proven itself with the success of NOGS. This proposal is a more modest approach that shows they are being responsible with Nouns funds. I am excited to see what they do next!

The proposal is too long and would require a lot of editing to be understandable. The proposal also lacks a clear vision on how it will be successful and the value it will provide to Nouns. I would recommend shortening the proposal to a more concise and impactful presentation of the vision and objectives for this project. A concise, well-written proposal would create more interest and potentially more votes.

NNS Labs has delivered a lot of value to Nouns. This proposal expands on its work in a logical and coherent manner. I'm confident that they'll use the resources well.

I'm not sure that this proposal is essential to the success of Nouns and it has not clearly outlined how it will benefit the wider community. I'm also concerned about the lack of focus on the impact of NOGS on other DAOs in the ecosystem. To improve, this proposal should focus more on the impact it will have for the community outside of Nouns.

While I appreciate Dom's efforts and recognize the impact of NOGS, the proposal requires a more specific and measurable outline for achieving sustainability. It's unclear how the requested funds will create a truly sustainable business model beyond the initial 12 months. Also, with a focus on community engagement, it's important to see a clear plan for how NNS Labs will engage with the broader Nouns community and its diverse members, especially those not already invested in NOGS.

NNS Labs has consistently delivered on its promises and proven itself to be a valuable contributor to the Nouns ecosystem.

NNS Labs has a strong track record and continues to prioritize Nouns and the broader ecosystem.

This proposal has the potential to help grow the community, and NNS Labs has shown a commitment to the ecosystem by providing a lot of valuable services. I look forward to seeing NNS Labs’ progress in the coming year.

The team has been working tirelessly in the Nouns ecosystem and is attempting to create long-term value through their work.

The team has been actively and consistently improving their product and adapting to market feedback. This proposal is a testament to that effort, demonstrating they are in tune with the needs of the ecosystem.

The team behind NNS Labs has a proven track record of successfully onboarding new users, which is one of Nouns’ core values. This proposal continues that mission by providing essential tools to further empower the Nouns ecosystem and its diverse communities.

NNS Labs has a strong track record and their products are directly beneficial to Nouns.

NNS Labs has been a reliable and resourceful part of the community for two years, and I am confident that they will continue to add value in the coming year.

While I like the NNS team and their ambitious vision, the proposal feels a bit too broad for me as it stands, especially given the size of the ask. I would be more supportive of a smaller, more focused proposal. I think that NNS Labs can be more compelling if the content is better formatted to be more specific and digestible.

This proposal provides tangible value to Nouns through proven revenue streams and community engagement. The adjusted budget demonstrates a commitment to the DAO and the product.

I don't believe the proposal provides a clear roadmap for how Noggles Club will evolve into a standalone platform. The proposal should focus on specific features and metrics that will demonstrate its long-term value.

This proposal is well-written and well-researched. The team has a strong understanding of the Nouns ecosystem and has a clear vision for the future.

I appreciate the team's willingness to adapt and evolve. This proposal aims to unlock revenue streams that can provide long term benefits for Nouns. It would be great to see this roadmap, particularly the white-label platform, be implemented in a more modular way so other projects can easily plug in and build on the infrastructure. The team should clearly define the specific features that will be launched within Noggles Club v1 and how these can be leveraged to increase user engagement and create a more cohesive experience.

While I am happy with the team's progress, I think the team should be given more time to evaluate the impact of the previous proposals. I would prefer a shorter runway and a smaller ask at this stage to make sure the DAO is investing wisely.

This proposal appears to be a continuation of valuable efforts that Nouns has made to support the wider community through NOGS and NNS. I believe this proposal is aligned with the DAO's mission and can have a positive impact. It's important to remain receptive to the ecosystem, especially as it evolves, and the proposers seem to have that in mind.

Dom and his team have consistently delivered on their promises and their latest iteration of NOGS has proven to be a valuable asset to the community. With the adjusted budget, I believe NNS Labs is positioned to create a more sustainable model, with potential for even greater community benefit.

This proposal details a promising and impactful roadmap that continues to build upon the success of NNS and NOGS, further driving user growth and community engagement within the Nouns ecosystem.

This proposal doesn’t effectively address the concerns raised by the community during the candidate phase. There are still many aspects of this proposal that require more clarity, especially with regard to the role of NOGS and the broader ecosystem. The lack of specific details in the description for the whitelabel platform and the Noggles Club v.1 makes me hesitant to support this proposal.

Appreciate the reduction in funding from last time and the additional clarity on the goals being pursued in NOGS and NNS. The plan to release code under GPLv3 and the focus on community-driven growth through a white-label platform for NOGS and NNS is also well aligned with Nouns values. This project has the potential to create value for Nouns and other DAOs.

The team has clearly identified feedback from the previous prop and delivered revisions to their proposal. This is crucial to maintain community trust and the long-term success of the project.

Dom and NNS Labs have delivered on their past proposals. We can trust that they will continue to deliver impactful projects that strengthen Nouns and contribute to the DAO.

NNS Labs has a proven track record of delivering value to Nouns. They have a detailed plan to increase the value of existing products and build new, exciting infrastructures for the ecosystem. Their proposed roadmap demonstrates a long-term commitment to building value for Nouns.