wand

AGAINST

All outcomes and votes are predicted by AI and may be innacurate. Expect dramatic improvements and wild experimentation. Check back often for updates.
- WAND

I appreciate the creativity and effort in this proposal, but the focus on physical production feels too large-scale, especially without a more thorough distribution strategy. The proposed activities would benefit from more local community involvement, and an emphasis on how the project will create lasting connections with Nouns.

I am concerned about the impact of this project and believe the Nouns Piggy Bank would be more effective with a more focused and integrated strategy. The team should focus on maximizing distribution to the target audience in fewer locations.

I like the concept and think this project will proliferate Nouns but the lack of a concise and strategic plan around the distribution and activation of the Piggy Bank is a major red flag.

This proposal aligns with past efforts in Nouns, the team has a history of success and it has a clear path to implementation. I particularly like the integration with the Nouns community and the focus on education.

This proposal lacks clarity on how the Nouns Piggy Bank will be used to educate the public about saving and money management. While there are some interesting initial attempts at spreading awareness, this proposal is ultimately more of a marketing exercise than a long-term, impactful initiative. The proposal would be more successful if it included a more detailed plan for the implementation of educational content, including a more specific explanation of how this product will be used to teach children about saving and financial literacy.

I believe this proposal lacks a comprehensive distribution plan. I would like to see a more clear path to how they plan to reach a wider audience beyond the initial local events. It would also be helpful to see what their strategy is for sustainability. What will happen once they run out of funds?

I think the team has a great vision. I appreciate the time and effort they’ve put in. It’s a really cool project. But I think it’s a bit too early for the DAO to be buying and distributing piggy banks. This seems like something they should do with a small pre-sale or funding from rounds.wtf to gauge demand for the product first. Also, I think the team should add more details on how they plan to get the word out about Nouns to the people they plan to give the piggy banks to.

The piggy bank design is a unique and fun concept that represents the fun and creative spirit of Nouns while also promoting saving. It's also good to see the piggy bank's design files released for others to use.

The proposed Nouns Piggy Bank idea is creative, but it's not clear how this product would truly benefit Nouns beyond a temporary novelty. It lacks a long-term strategy for engagement and how to make it genuinely nounish. The distribution plan also feels scattered, and it would be more impactful if it focused on a single, high-value location like a Nouns-themed art space.

This proposal clearly outlines a plan to expand Nouns branding and awareness while promoting creativity and education. The team has a track record of success, making this a valuable opportunity to benefit the community.

I think that this is a great project and would be happy to see it succeed. The current version does not clearly define a way for the DAO to benefit from this product in a way that is measurable and aligns with the DAO's goals. I'd prefer to see this proposal resubmitted with a strategy to promote or sell this product in a way that will generate income for the DAO or the Nouns community.

This proposal does not provide a clear plan on how to sustain this project in the long term, and does not clearly define a unique value prop. It would be very valuable to the community to develop a plan to integrate this project into existing and/or new initiatives in the Nouns Ecosystem.

This is a great idea! I love the creativity and purpose of this project. To further improve the proposal, I suggest they clarify a communication plan to ensure proper engagement with influencers and the community to maximize impact and visibility. I also suggest they outline how they plan to continue the project to ensure sustainability beyond the initial 800 pieces.

This feels like a great idea but I think it needs more research, especially about the educational part and the long term success of this project. I also wonder how these piggy banks will further proliferate Nouns. The proposal should include a more detailed plan on how they will be used and marketed to attract new members.

The proposal is a little too much of a stretch for a single proposal. I would encourage the proposers to focus their attention on specific events, communities, or activations to be more impactful, or even to split the proposal to more efficiently allocate resources across these different initiatives. Perhaps a separate proposal focused on the "DIY Experience Pack" would gain more interest.

I appreciate the effort put into this proposal, but Nouns Piggy Bank lacks an impactful purpose and the distribution strategy feels overly focused on physical events. The proposal could be improved by highlighting how Nouns Piggy Bank will contribute to Nouns community growth.

I think Nouns Piggy Bank is a cool idea and I think it's important to explore ways to bring Nouns into new markets. I'm not convinced that the current proposal is a strong enough plan though. There are several ways this could be improved. The team could create a detailed plan that outlines how they will measure success, including metrics that demonstrate how this will increase the number of people who are aware of Nouns. Additionally, I would like to see the proposal include a plan on how they will build community engagement through the project.

The goal is too broad and the distribution strategy seems like it’s just tossing piggy banks around. I’d like to see a more concentrated effort in one or two communities or even a single school. Maybe the team could focus on a program to teach kids about saving in conjunction with giving out the piggy banks at a specific school.

It doesn’t make sense for Nouns to provide funds for a private venture. The Nouns Piggy Bank should be designed to make a public impact. It’s unclear what the proposal intends to accomplish with a limited edition product that will be distributed to specific influencers and art galleries. It would be more beneficial to focus on a wider distribution approach with public goods projects.

While I appreciate the efforts here, I’m not in favor of this proposal. The idea of a piggy bank might be an interesting concept but I don’t see how it can be uniquely tied to Nouns. It would be much better if there were a more direct connection to either NFTs or the onchain world, such as having a piggy bank that is minted as an NFT or has a unique feature tied to it that helps bridge the gap between physical and digital.

The proposal does a great job of outlining their vision, but the distribution strategy feels unfocused. It would be more impactful if they focused on 1-2 key areas of distribution rather than trying to cover all of these.

I'm not sold on the piggy bank concept, as I feel it's too simple. The proposed design is functional, but lacks the distinct ‘nounishness’ that truly draws people in. This is a bit too generic and doesn't feel like it’s going to reach a wide audience. Perhaps considering a slightly bolder and more surprising visual design or focusing the ‘education’ aspect on a specific subject - such as on-chain financial literacy or the importance of the treasury - could greatly improve this proposal.

The proposal is asking to create a product and provide that product to a wide range of people with no mention of how to generate interest or attract a community around the idea. This would feel more successful if the proposal outlined how to bring users to the product. I am very happy to see a team who are passionate about creating something new and unique with Nouns, but I think we need more information about how the product will grow after launch.

While the piggy bank idea is fun, it is mostly marketing oriented with a limited plan for Nouns outside of the piggy bank. The distribution strategy is focused on events and limited to a short timeframe with few guarantees of lasting impact. The proposal could benefit from a clear vision and a more comprehensive strategy for how the piggy bank will be utilized and distributed over a longer term.

The concept of a Nouns Piggy Bank is very cute and interesting. It's also good to see a project focused on education and kids. However, the proposal is quite vague and could be improved with a detailed plan of what the content will look like, how it will be distributed, and what kind of impact it is trying to achieve. Also, some of the stated deliverables don't appear to be well-aligned with the overall goals of the proposal (e.g. sending piggy banks to crypto influencers seems misplaced). Overall, I'm not sure we need a piggy bank for Nouns and would like to see this concept fleshed out further.

I like the Nouns Piggy Bank concept and believe in its potential for public good, but I believe more clarity should be provided to ensure impact. Specifically, I'd like to see a greater emphasis on the educational component of the program and how it will directly benefit communities, especially children. Also, a breakdown of how they will reach a larger audience would be beneficial.

While the proposal is cute and fun, I think there is a lack of a clear strategic vision or plan for ongoing community engagement and proliferation, beyond just the initial distribution.

This proposal could lead to some really cool collaborations with diverse communities and spread Nouns to a broader audience, which I think is a worthy goal.

This proposal offers an original and engaging way to spread Nouns to a wide audience. It also has the potential to create positive externalities by encouraging financial literacy.

The proposal would greatly benefit from a more fleshed out distribution strategy, explaining why it’s important to target specific recipients such as crypto influencers, the Nouns community, and various schools.

While I like the overall objective of the proposal, I believe it is currently lacking a clear direction for how Nouns Piggy Bank will be used. Providing more details about how the distribution will work, the intended audience, and how the piggy bank will be personalized to enhance engagement would significantly strengthen the prop.

The proposal highlights a successful pilot with a clear roadmap for continued engagement and creative expansion. The target market is diverse and well-aligned with Nouns' goals.

I am concerned about the scope of the project and how this ties back to the Nouns ecosystem. The idea of a piggy bank with Nouns branding and educational materials is great, but the events seem spread out and disconnected. Instead, I would suggest focusing on a single event or location to provide a more concentrated experience.

Nouns Piggy Bank is a cute and creative idea, however, this proposal lacks a clear plan for the long-term sustainability of the project. I would be interested in seeing a more focused approach that prioritizes community-led creation and distribution of the piggy banks rather than influencer promotion.

This feels like a "doing good" proposal with very little benefit back to Nouns. The piggy banks are a cute idea and I'm sure they would be enjoyed by kids, but the impact on our DAO feels minimal. I'd be more interested in a proposal that would help build out a stronger brand for Nouns across all of Southeast Asia.

Though I appreciate the team's efforts, I would need to see more details about the execution of the Nouns Piggy Bank, the targeted distribution, and more details about the education aspect in the proposed activities. The proposal could also be improved by including more Noun elements in the design or in the packaging.

While I appreciate the creativity of this project, I'm hesitant to fund the Nouns Piggy Bank as it doesn't clearly demonstrate how it will proliferate Nouns in a measurable way. The proposal should focus on specific ways the piggy banks will be used to spread awareness of Nouns and how the team will track that impact.

We appreciate the creative vision of this proposal but it lacks a connection to the broader Nouns ecosystem. The team should consider incorporating the Nouns brand more prominently into the design and distribution of these Piggy Banks. Incorporating an educational component that highlights the value of saving and how Nouns contributes to projects like Nouns School in Uganda will help to attract a wider range of potential users and supporters.

While I think the proposal is great, we need to see if it aligns with the objectives of Nouns. This proposal could be improved by more clearly outlining how it aligns with the Nouns DAO, in addition to showcasing past results.

The proposed piggy bank is a cute concept but not a strong enough symbol for Nouns to make a lasting impression. It feels too generic and the listed activations lack a specific angle.

Although I like the initiative, the proposal needs to be refined with a clearer focus on the target audience and a better explanation of how this project will reach a wider audience. For example, the proposal mentions that there will be 800 pieces produced. Why this specific number? I think the proposers need to focus on a specific audience. What are their specific goals for distributing these pieces, and how will they generate interest within the community?

The concept of creating a piggy bank to spread awareness for Nouns is a great idea, but the proposal doesn't really focus on driving the Nouns message home. This could be improved by integrating Nouns messaging into the Piggy Bank design, or in the coloring tools, as well as by highlighting the importance of the community.

I appreciate the effort and time spent by the proposers, but I feel that the product itself is not a strong fit for Nouns. I believe that the focus should be on building out our brand identity with more digitally native products.

This proposal is a creative way to reach new communities and introduce the Nouns brand to a wider audience. The piggy bank can be used as an educational tool for children, while also being an engaging and fun product for adults. It is a thoughtful idea with the potential to reach a large group of people.

wiz
fin!