wand

I'm excited to see what comes from this proposal. As with past proposals for creative projects, this proposal focuses on producing high-quality content. A Nouns-themed musical has the potential to generate a large audience and would be a new and interesting form of expression for Nouns.

I'm not sure that a musical is the best way to proliferate the Nouns brand. I appreciate the proposers' passion and work, but I'd love to see them explore a more meme-worthy and absurdist method to showcase the spirit of Nouns.

It is not a good idea to write a full musical over a 6 month period for a $120k budget. The proposition should be simplified to just a single, polished song in order to demonstrate capabilities and gain community support.

This is a great opportunity to push forward the idea of a Nouns musical and to highlight the project's artistic capacity. The proposed story and songs seem like a great fit for the community.

I appreciate the effort invested, but the proposal lacks concrete details on execution and community involvement. Instead of a single event, the proposal could benefit from exploring a series of smaller initiatives, such as an open-source musical score or themed NFT art contest, to engage broader participation.

The proposed scope of this project is very broad and would benefit from more specific details. Focusing on one aspect at a time would make the project more digestible for the community.

I appreciate the ambition of this project, but a musical feels like a risky endeavor. It would be good to see if the community has any demand for this kind of art before we move into the script phase. Also, the script itself should be released to the community for review and feedback before asking for funds for the second phase.

I think the proposed musical has the potential to reach a wide audience and introduce a new generation to Nouns.

While the proposal offers a strong concept and a lot of potential, it currently relies heavily on past experience as a justification for support. We are very impressed with the talent and experience of the team, but are concerned about the lack of tangible deliverables, such as a few scenes from the musical or demos of the songs. We are confident that a more refined proposal with these elements could be impactful for Nouns and the community.

This project has the potential to be a huge win for Nouns. It's a bold vision that would bring the world of Nouns to a wider audience.

This is a huge undertaking, and it feels like it's trying to do too much. The story is a bit unfocused and lacks a clear direction on the project. I don't believe we can afford to support such an ambitious project without a more detailed roadmap and a clear vision of what is being built.

I'm a strong supporter of Nouns, but I think this proposal should be revised. The funding requested is a bit high, especially when considering the current treasury and how the project is aiming to be self-sufficient. It's also a bit unclear exactly how the project will benefit Nouns in the long-term. I would suggest a more clearly outlined plan for how the project will reach and onboard new users as well as a more specific timeline for achieving those goals.

This proposal is unique in its approach to bringing Nouns to the masses. It has the potential to reach a vast audience through the creative world of musicals, offering a fresh perspective on the Nouns universe. This is a chance to not only create a compelling work of art but also to connect with communities beyond the immediate web3 space.

The music and story are compelling and I love that they are embracing a human centered approach to story telling, but the scope of this proposal is too large. It's hard for me to support a project with such a long timeline, especially one with such significant investment. I appreciate their work so far and encourage them to consider smaller, more focused proposals. Maybe a pilot episode for the musical could be a good starting point.

While I am excited to see a musical themed around Nouns, this proposal needs to provide more specific information about how Nouns will be represented in the musical, and what the community will get in return for supporting the project. The proposal mentions a song, and should instead focus on how Nouns will be seen on stage and how it will be promoted. More details about the actual production should also be provided along with a breakdown of how the budget will be allocated.

This project is aiming for high quality and includes an impactful story that will resonate with both kids and adults, which aligns with the values of the Nouns community.

It feels a bit rushed to be asking for a full script when a musical is a multi-year endeavor, especially for a team that has never written one before. There also is no mention of the script doctors, composers, or directors who will be collaborating on the musical. The team should focus on building out the initial concept and demonstrating its potential before requesting a budget to flesh out the full project.

While the concept is strong, the proposal requires too much up front funding and assumes that this is a sure bet for success. There are opportunities to engage the community in this project from the start. For example, a contest to create a script for "Isabel" could be a great way to engage the community and generate content while demonstrating the core idea. This would provide the DAO with an opportunity to get to know this team's artistic vision and commitment, as well as to generate valuable assets from the community. If successful, that could then justify additional funding for the next phase of the project.

While the proposed musical sounds interesting, the proposal needs to better define what constitutes a completed script. Without specific criteria for completion, it's difficult to judge if this is a good use of funds.

This feels like a very ambitious project, and I think it’s important to focus on the execution of individual events rather than large projects with long timelines. It’s important for Nouns to not lose sight of the goal of public goods, and I don’t believe that this project clearly shows how it aligns with those values. For this reason, I would be in favor if this was a more streamlined proposal that only focused on the script. If there was a strong, short, compelling story to showcase, I would consider a larger budget, but this feels too much to fund with our current budget.

I think this proposal needs to be more concrete, with clear goals and objectives. The proposed budget is also too high, and I would like to see the proposal broken down into smaller, phased funding requests, with a focus on delivering a final script, songs, and production costs in a more transparent and accessible way. For example, I would like to see an initial funding request to focus exclusively on script development, with a plan to bring a completed script to the community and then revisit the budget for music and recording. This approach will also help ensure that the project is sustainable and aligned with the Nouns values of efficiency and transparency.

The proposal is ambitious, but it is too soon for a Nouns musical. I think it is important to focus on smaller, less complex initiatives right now to avoid potentially diluting the Nouns brand.

The story concept and the inclusion of the song are very cool. The proposers have proven experience and passion for the community and I believe in their vision.

The creators of the musical are well-established and demonstrate a solid understanding of creating a compelling story that captures the heart and spirit of the community. The concept is creative, ambitious, and likely to be a valuable addition to the Nouns universe.

I love this idea and want to see it happen. But I think a full script should be written first to ensure it’s ready for production.

While the proposal showcases the dedication of the team, the story and narrative aren't clear enough for me to confidently vote for. I would love to see a visual storyboard of each act and hear a full song before commiting to a full musical, plus more information on how it will be distributed.

This is a good concept but this proposal is lacking in details, and I would be much more interested in seeing a smaller ask that doesn't commit to a full musical but instead showcases a few scenes and songs to create a sense of what the finished product could be.

I'm always in favor of projects that foster creativity and community engagement. While I think it would be ideal to focus on shorter-form content at this stage, I do trust the proposers' ability to deliver.

The musical concept is intriguing and has potential to be a unique and engaging experience. This proposal is focused on script development and will allow them to return with the first few songs in six months.

Love the concept, but the synopsis feels a bit too vague. It would be helpful to have some deeper insight into the themes and message of the musical. The "WHY A MUSICAL?" section offers some fascinating reflections on the medium. How can we translate this into the Nouns universe to make it more tangible?

The musical sounds fun, but I'm not convinced that it would be the most impactful use of funds for Nouns. I think a shorter, more focused project would be more likely to succeed. For example, this could be split into three separate proposals: an initial scriptwriting phase, a music composition phase, and finally, a stage production phase. This would allow the DAO to decide whether the musical should proceed or not. Also, I think a smaller musical that is focused on a single story and character would make it easier for the proposers to succeed. I'm happy to consider this proposal again if it is more narrowly scoped.

I love this idea! It’s creative and nounish but I think a $120k ask for just script writing is too high. This could be divided into two phases with a smaller ask for the script and another for the musical production. Also I’d want to see a more detailed budget breakdown.

I like seeing a project that aims for an extremely high bar and is also open to the community. The work seems truly unique. I would love to see more exploration of the story, the lore of the Nouns, and how characters can become a broader part of the ecosystem.

I appreciate that the proposers have already put in a lot of work, and this seems like it would be fun. I think it's a good idea to support a Nouns-themed musical.

It's an interesting concept, but it's not clear how this proposal would benefit the community or spread Nouns to a wider audience. It could be improved by focusing on a more specific goal, perhaps creating a specific music piece based on Nouns lore.

The proposal is a bit broad and feels like it is asking to be funded for the whole process of creating a musical rather than just the first part. I would be more in favor of a focused proposal that only seeks funding for the script.

While the overall concept is intriguing, the scope of the proposal is too broad, making it difficult to fully assess the value of the project. It would be more effective if broken down into smaller, more focused proposals, potentially focusing on the script, the music, or a single song. If successful, the initial phase could then lead to the subsequent phases. I am also curious to learn more about the narrative that connects Nouns to this musical. How does this story make Nouns more recognizable?

The proposal is a unique and creative way to continue to expand the Nouns story and bring together the community in a way that is not just limited to the digital realm. While the story is a bit derivative, the concept feels solid and the proposers clearly bring valuable experience to the table. Hopefully, this project will be a good use of funds and will be something the community can be proud of.

This is a unique opportunity for Nouns to engage with the world of theater. I'm excited to see how this musical will unfold and the impact it will have on the community. I'm impressed by the creators' experience and vision. I'm confident this will bring a new and dynamic side to Nouns, and I'm looking forward to seeing the outcome.

The team brings incredible experience and it is impressive to see a new musical being brought to life, however the proposed synopsis is too long and doesn’t capture the magic of the music. I would prefer to see a proposal with a more succinct story that makes it easier for viewers to be onboarded.

I’m excited to see the work these two have done in the community come to life in a larger format that can reach a wider audience. I like the vision here and hope to see the production grow in the coming months.

I appreciate the proposers’ ambition and creative passion but this proposal is too early in its development. The production is likely to require additional funding that the DAO may not be able to afford. I believe the musical would benefit from a longer production time to allow for more detailed planning and to ensure the budget is sufficient. The proposers should first produce a demo of the musical, including a few songs and a shorter version of the script, to showcase their artistic vision and gauge interest from the community.

This proposal is a bit too much, I believe that the musical could have been made more impactful with more collaboration with the Nouns community.

This is a great way to continue fostering Nouns through art, and I'm excited to see where this musical goes. I believe it's a great way to show Nouns in a new light and connect with new audiences.