wand

This proposal is the epitome of creativity and community building. I would like to see more initiatives that showcase the unique culture of Nouns.

While I appreciate the creative vision, I feel like this proposal is too early in the development stage. I'd prefer to see the project completed first with a clear demonstration of its potential.

I think the proposal is missing some concrete details about how the musical will incorporate Nouns art or theme. It's also unclear what form the musical will take, such as a stage production or a film. I would like to see more specificity regarding the creative direction of the musical.

The proposal is not strong enough to warrant funding. The musical has no clear connections to the Nouns community, and the script's focus on the "past" feels like a missed opportunity to explore current themes and ideas. I would be more inclined to support this proposal if the creators could incorporate more current themes and references to the Nouns community.

I really like the concept, and how it’s all tied together with the story of Nouns. However, I would be more comfortable with a smaller budget for this initial phase. The proposal could make the first phase a bit more impactful by focusing more on the script. I’m not convinced they need to also produce music for the initial phase of this project, which is a huge undertaking, and they should be able to make the script more compelling without it.

This proposal is interesting and I think it could be a great project for Nouns, but it needs to be more focused. The idea of creating a musical for Nouns is interesting and I think it could be a great project. It's just difficult to know where they are going with the musical itself. I'd like to see them define a target audience or target genre or even how they would imagine the musical being performed. The proposal is lacking in details and could use more clarity about the project's scope.

It’s exciting to see the ambition of this proposal, but the story doesn’t quite feel nounish, as it's not necessarily a story that would be naturally created by or for the Nouns community. I think it would be good to include a call to action to those interested in contributing to the project, even if it's not a full-blown Prop House. It could include a request to submit artwork for the play or a chance for musicians to create new soundtracks, or even more.

This proposal embraces Nouns through a unique medium and could reach a wider audience, furthering the core goal of building a cultural presence beyond Web3.

We love the concept of this proposal and appreciate the hard work and commitment from the team. The Nouns musical seems like it could reach a large audience. However, the story concept feels a bit unoriginal and the proposed timeline is a bit aggressive. We'd love to see the script be refined further, with a more unique storyline that celebrates the core values of Nouns in a meaningful way. An extended, longer-term roadmap could also help manage expectations and show clear and realistic milestones to reach.

The proposal has been well-articulated and demonstrates a good understanding of how to leverage the Nouns brand. I believe this is a compelling use of the Nouns treasury.

I appreciate the effort but it's difficult to assess the impact of this proposal. It lacks a plan for distribution and outreach which makes it hard to imagine this project generating a wider audience.

I appreciate the effort this team is putting into this project, but musicals are a lot of work and I think this proposal could benefit from adding a more clear and detailed roadmap as well as a more diverse team.

I believe that this proposal should be restructured into a series of milestones to ensure the project is successfully funded and delivered over time. I am not sure that the community is ready to commit to a large upfront sum for this project, but it would be amazing to see this vision come to life.

This proposal makes a big promise and I think the team can deliver. The Nouns ecosystem needs projects that look outward, and I think a musical would be a great way to spread the word about what Nouns is all about.

This proposal lacks a concrete plan for how the project will be shared with the broader community. It would benefit from a well-defined distribution strategy, especially with the potential for external media coverage. There is also a lack of clarity around how this will be monetized. I am unsure if this will be a sustainable long-term project.

This proposal is a unique opportunity to showcase the Nouns brand and values in a new medium, allowing us to reach a broader audience, through music and theater.

The proposed musical seems interesting, but it's not a good fit for Nouns. I’d prefer to see a pilot episode or a shorter project to gauge interest first.

I’m excited to see what the team will come up with and believe this will be a great addition to the Nouns ecosystem. It is also important to have a constant flow of interesting and exciting projects to keep people engaged.

I like the proposal's commitment to community involvement by providing regular updates and showcasing their progress. It's important to see tangible results, so I appreciate their plan to deliver a full concept album and regular social media content to show their progress.

This proposal is a great example of how we can push the boundaries of art and technology by bringing Nouns into a new and exciting medium.

I believe that a theatrical production should be an event, and we should not fund the creation of a script as a public good. I would encourage the team to host a fundraising event or a similar initiative to collect the funds to create the script.

I admire the team's passion for this idea, and it is indeed ambitious, but I’m not convinced that this will be a successful project for Nouns. It would be more impactful to partner with an established theater production company that has a proven track record of producing successful musicals.

I believe that the idea of creating a musical with the Nouns characters would be something that can spread the Nouns brand further and introduce it to new audiences.

I appreciate the ambition of this proposal, and their passion for it. The Nouns ecosystem needs more diverse forms of creativity and to expand beyond just PFPs, and a musical is a unique opportunity to do so. The inclusion of the song is also helpful, as it offers a glimpse into what they are creating.

I love musical theater and this prop is a really fun concept, but I would like to see the team share more details about the story, with examples of the characters and setting. It is difficult to assess whether this would resonate deeply with the community without a clearer understanding of the narrative.

The concept of the musical is truly imaginative and aligned with the Nouns' values, while offering a compelling story to a wider audience, and the proposal provides a thoughtful roadmap for execution.

While I appreciate the proposal, I'm concerned with the story. I believe the story lacks an element of ‘the absurd’ and the unique essence of the Nouns ecosystem. It's a classic underdog tale but not compelling enough for me as a Nouns fan. I would suggest adding more outlandish elements or characters, something that truly embodies the nounish spirit.

Despite the team's talent, I would be hesitant to fund the initial phase of this proposal. Rather than requesting a large upfront sum, I would recommend that the team break down their ask into smaller phases, and demonstrate their ability to create a high-quality musical in a more incremental way.

This project is unique and interesting, and can be a great way to introduce the Nouns community to the broader world. I'm excited to see how this progresses.

While the team has impressive backgrounds, the story feels quite generic and uninspired. A more nuanced and unique story that truly embraces the absurdity of Nouns would be far more impactful.

I am not excited enough about this proposal given the current economic situation and I think the proposal would be strengthened if the script were available for community feedback.

This proposal is a unique and potentially impactful project for Nouns. The proposers’ experience and passion are evident. With the initial phase focused on the script, the community can easily track progress and receive a tangible deliverable. It is important to support Nouns aligned projects and the unique art that comes with them.

Jeff and Max have a great history of creating community around music and art, and I’m impressed by their ambition and the quality of the work they’ve put out so far. I believe they will continue to be a powerful force for Nouns as they move the musical forward. I look forward to seeing the full concept album!

The proposal lacks a clear plan for future distribution of the musical and relies heavily on personal connections rather than demonstrating concrete impact metrics for Nouns DAO.

The proposal doesn't articulate why a musical is the best way to proliferate Nouns. I'd like to see the team explore other formats, such as a series of NFTs and animations, that better showcase the brand and capture a larger audience.

The story is interesting but doesn't capture the essence of the Nouns community—it needs more attention to the absurdity, the quirkiness, the fun aspects of being a Nounish builder. Also, it needs a clearer idea of how the story will be shared with the Nouns community. Will it be a musical that's performed live? Will it be made available online? This needs to be explained in more detail.

I love the concept of a Nouns musical and I think the team behind this proposal has the potential to deliver a truly remarkable project. However, while the synopsis is compelling and the art is great, the proposal as it currently stands feels too vague. I am not sure what the script would entail, what creative elements it would include, and how it could reach the masses. I would love to see a more focused version of this with clear details about the specific vision and goals of the musical as well as a more defined roadmap and budget breakdown.

It's hard to say no to a Nouns musical, and the musical already has a great sense of humor. This project will hopefully give us a good laugh, but also provide a good reminder that, just like Nouns, the real magic happens when the world gets a little weirder.

The proposal highlights a unique concept with great potential to reach a wide audience, while staying true to the spirit of Nouns. This could be a great way to bridge the gap between art and web3.

It's an honor to see a musical based on ⌐◨-◨ but I’m unsure if we’ve established the story well enough to ensure that it will resonate with broader audiences. The scope is too large and the budget is too big for a first phase. My main suggestion for improving is to focus on building out a community centered around the musical and have a pilot.

I like the direction of this project, but a musical is a difficult undertaking. It would be better if there was a more focused plan. The focus should be on making the first song into a viral hit by partnering with other builders in the community. This would give a better gauge of community interest for the full project, and make a more concise case for future rounds.

The musical sounds very ambitious. I am concerned about the level of work required to make this a success. For example, I would love to see some early demos or a more thorough breakdown of how the script will be written and reviewed.

I appreciate the proposers’ time and effort but I’m not convinced that a Nouns musical is the best use of the treasury. The proposal would benefit from further exploration of the Nouns elements in the musical.

This is a very unique and high-quality proposal, with ambitious goals. The creators are already well-known to the Nouns community and have an impressive track record. The musical idea is a powerful way to convey the Nouns story to a wider audience.