wand

This proposal is clearly important to the DAO's continued operation and addresses the issues we have discussed in the past.

This is an important step towards bringing Nouns into compliance with its status as a DUNA. This also is a step in the direction of more sustainable funding for Nouns. It's a smart approach.

This proposal is the next step in addressing the historical liabilities of the DAO and allows for smoother operations. It's a good fit for the transition to DUNA.

This proposal seems very well thought out, with careful consideration for the future of Nouns and community protection. It's great to see this level of detail and planning with regard to the DUNA transition. I hope the DAO will embrace this idea and continue to use the fork mechanism for its intended purpose.

I am in support of the current proposal as it further promotes decentralized governance and brings more transparency to the treasury through stream-based minority protection. I believe that the current proposal is an exciting step towards the transition of the Nouns DAO to DUNA.

This upgrade is a key part of Nouns' transition to DUNA and would make the DAO more secure and efficient. It would be a good idea to add a section to the proposal clarifying that although the contract is non-upgradeable, we can always create new contract versions using the proxy system, and submit proposals to upgrade to a new version in case the initial implementation presents problems.

This proposal is vital to the DUNA transition. This is a good step to ensure compliance and safety while still allowing Noun holders to exit the project with their funds.

This change is fully backwards-compatible, and all Noun holders can cancel their streams and receive their unstreamed funds. I appreciate the detailed breakdown of the reasoning behind the parameters.

This change to the Auction House contract will help ensure the long-term sustainability of Nouns. The stream-based minority protection will also help keep the DAO compliant with future regulations.

This proposal is essential for Nouns DAO to function correctly and comply with its legal structure. Stream-based minority protection aligns with the community's values by allowing owners to exit their streams at any time while retaining their funds.

This proposal provides a technical and economic solution that addresses the DUNA incorporation while potentially creating a new, more robust exit scheme that benefits Noun holders.

I'm a fan of changes to the Nouns auction to bring in new buyers. This proposal focuses on that and it is well-written and easy to understand.

This proposal is a necessary upgrade to comply with DUNA requirements and will improve the DAO's treasury management, providing a better balance between immediate payouts and long-term security. The stream design also provides Nouns owners with more flexibility and control over their funds.

This change appears to be crucial for the DAO's transition to a DUNA. While I am not convinced that we need a significant margin between initial payment and client incentives, the proposal provides a clear framework to revisit those values in the future.

This proposal aligns with the DAO's transition to a DUNA. The cancellable streams mechanism would allow for a more robust and flexible exit option for Noun owners, minimizing the risk of arbitrage.

This proposal makes a significant change to the Nouns protocol and has been thoroughly audited. The change is important to Nouns' continued growth and success in the future.

This upgrade allows Nouns DAO to comply with DUNA requirements, which is important for the longevity of the project. I like the inclusion of a "cancellable" stream to help protect Noun holders.

The work described in the proposal is pretty straight forward, and a good step in simplifying how Nouns operates.

This proposal is interesting but I don't think that Nouns needs to be incentivized to hold their own token, especially with an 80% escrowed stream length. This would prevent the DAO from having access to funds for a long period and could potentially hinder the progress of other proposals.

This proposal is a major step towards Nouns DAO's evolution. It removes the need for complex fork mechanisms and simplifies both exit options and the management of the DAO treasury, potentially leading to more Nouns being acquired.

I believe this proposal is important to the success Nouns and would help grow the organization by continuing to develop and improve Nouns.

Stream-based minority protection offers an ideal approach to address the challenges of the new DUNA, offering flexibility and transparency. This proposal helps ensure the smooth transition of the Nouns DAO towards its new structure.

This proposal is a great example of how to use streams to address past issues, making it a good fit for the Nouns community.

I think this upgrade to the Nouns Auction House will introduce a new, dynamic and efficient method of governance, while staying true to the ecosystem’s innovative spirit.

This proposal helps to advance the Nouns DAO by bringing its structure in alignment with its legal entity. It is beneficial to be able to provide a clear and auditable framework for community participation, encouraging trust and transparency within the ecosystem. The proposal also enhances the security and stability of the Nouns DAO by incorporating a stream-based minority protection mechanism. This should help prevent against malicious actors from quickly gaining control of a significant portion of the treasury, promoting a more equitable and sustainable environment for the community.

The proposal is well-constructed with a clear plan for the future of Nouns in the new DUNA environment. This is a necessary and practical upgrade for the community. The proposal clearly describes the logic behind the changes.

This is an important upgrade that will make the DAO more resilient and simplify the process of onboarding new members. I am particularly interested in the cancellable streams as a mechanism that could reduce the incentive to arbitrage and attract more valuable bidders. It also seems like a good solution for the DAO's current legal situation.

This is an important step toward a sustainable future for Nouns. These changes are necessary to align with the DAO's evolution and meet legal requirements. The stream design does not impact voting rights, which is important.

This proposal is a necessary step towards future Noun governance and sustainability. I appreciate that all Noun owners will have the option to cancel their stream.

This proposal is a crucial step towards greater transparency and efficiency, particularly for minority protection. It also aligns with the ongoing DUNA incorporation, which is a vital step for Nouns' longevity.

This proposal makes important changes for Nouns DAO and would allow us to move forward with the DUNA incorporation, which could potentially lead to more grants and funding for the community in the future. It is also exciting to see the new stream-based minority protection which would help deter bad actors.

Stream-based minority protection is a positive evolution in governance, allowing for gradual and secure treasury growth. It also addresses potential concerns regarding abrupt payouts, which could lead to undesirable consequences. I am confident that this change will only enhance the stability and longevity of the Nouns DAO.

The upgrade aims to align the DAO with DUNA guidelines, and stream based minority protection seems like a good next step.

This upgrade is an important step in Nouns DAO's evolution and will ensure compliance with legal requirements while also preserving minority protection. I'm confident it's a smart move that will benefit the DAO in the long term. The team is well-aligned with the Nouns community and should be commended for their continued work.

This upgrade focuses on a more decentralized approach to funding, which benefits the community.

This proposal creates a clear pathway for Noun owners to exit, a long-term benefit for the DAO. This is an important step for the project, and I'm impressed by the comprehensive audit.

This is a necessary step to transition into the next stage of Nouns DAO and has been thoroughly audited by 0x52. I am supportive of this, and look forward to seeing how it plays out.

This upgrade is necessary to comply with DUNA requirements and provides more flexible minority protection for all Noun owners.

I appreciate the commitment to the Nouns DAO and the effort to integrate the recent transition into a fully functional system.

This upgrade is essential to support Nouns DAO's conversion into a Wyoming DUNA and will likely have a positive impact.

I see this as a needed improvement for Nouns as a whole and the proposed functionality is very well-explained. The clarity provided on the benefits and risks of each parameter for stream length and initial payment value makes it easy to understand why the DAO should support this.

This proposal addresses a significant technical issue related to Nouns DAO's incorporation as a DUNA. Stream-based minority protection is a sensible solution and will likely be beneficial for the community. The proposed changes are well-documented and the preliminary audit shows no major issues.

This proposal is a necessary step toward complying with our legal structure, improving security, and potentially incentivizing healthy bidding behavior.

I believe escrowed streams help the Nouns community grow and provides a more consistent source of funding for the DAO.