wand

I am highly supportive of this project that will provide visual healthcare and education while proliferating the Nouns brand and fostering the values of the Nouns community.

I love this idea and think it's great! I'd like to see more details regarding how this can work. It feels a little rushed for such an ambitious project. It also needs a lot of external collaboration, which should be outlined in the proposal to make it more clear how this will be accomplished. I'd also like to see more specifics on how the mobile clinic and recycling station will be used. What kind of infrastructure will be in place for the project to last and be sustainable?

This proposal is a great way to proliferate Nouns and help kids in need at the same time. I also enjoy the focus on sustainability and education.

The proposal is focused on a specific geographic area and does not provide a clear way to expand beyond those communities. The project also seems to rely heavily on a single individual, which could create potential roadblocks. To make this more impactful, a comprehensive plan to onboard and engage a wider audience is needed.

I'm not sure this is a project Nouns should be funding - it feels like it's being used for the benefit of the creator rather than the DAO. I would be more interested if the project were focused on creating public goods that the community could directly benefit from rather than a private initiative.

This proposal is a great example of Nouns' dedication to social impact. The project is well-researched and has the potential to be impactful in a vulnerable community.

While this proposal is clearly aligned with the spirit of Nouns and the Precious Plastic community, I think it is too broad and lacks clear and specific details about how the project will proliferate Nouns in a meaningful way. I would be supportive of a proposal that focuses solely on the production and distribution of prescription glasses with a clear plan for media coverage and communication around the effort.

While I appreciate the intent and the focus on helping children, I feel that the project needs more community engagement and a more clear plan for how the Noggles will be used as a visual brand in a way that is in line with our identity. I believe this can be addressed through a clearer plan outlining how the Noggles will be utilized in the mobile clinic, and how a community-led design competition can drive participation and visual synergy.

This proposal is an incredible way to further proliferate the Nouns community with a project that has social and environmental impact.

Im not completely convinced by the concept of a mobile clinic and a recycling station. The proposed design is interesting, and I appreciate the social impact of the project. This idea, if refined, has the potential to become a great Nouns project. I would be happy to vote For if the team were to propose a smaller, focused experiment. This would allow for more direct impact and allow us to gather data before committing to a larger endeavor.

The proposal aims to directly impact 3,000 children in Rio de Janeiro by providing recycled eyeglasses. This initiative aligns with Nouns' values of creating a positive impact while promoting sustainability. The long-term objective of serving 15,000 children annually and replicating the project globally via open-source materials further enhances the proposal's impact and Nouns' global reach.

While I appreciate the goals and execution of the project, it feels like the budget is focused on the wrong aspects of the proposal.

This project will help introduce more people to Nouns, particularly a new demographic. I appreciate how it will highlight the environmental and social benefits of the Noggles design.

This proposal is focused on sustainable initiatives and community engagement that align with Nouns' core values.

This proposal lacks clear and specific information on how the funds will be used, especially for the mobile clinic and recycling station. The proposal also needs to provide better information about the timeline and milestones for project completion. There are no concrete plans for the project to be self-sustaining, which would be a critical component to consider going forward.

This proposal is a unique opportunity to leverage the Precious Plastic community and Noggles to make a tangible impact on children's lives while promoting recycling. This project aligns with Nouns' values of doing good and embracing technology.

The proposal lacks specifics on how the mobile clinic would be implemented, and a focus on the marketing plan rather than the impact of the program itself. I would encourage the proposers to focus on the user stories of the children they plan to help, and how their individual lives would be impacted by the program.

I love the spirit of this proposal and the commitment of the team behind it, but the scope feels too large to justify the current budget. I'd prefer to see a more focused proposal to gain traction and show initial success before expanding. This could be a shorter-term initiative that targets a smaller number of children in the initial stages, and then focuses on scaling up the project. It could also focus on specific aspects such as fundraising or educational workshops instead of trying to achieve everything at once.

This project has the potential to impact a lot of people and generate positive externalities. I think it's also great to see more focus on recycling and sustainability.

I am not confident that the proposal makes a clear and compelling case as to how it will benefit the Nouns community. The proposal should focus on the specific ways in which Precious Plastic can help Nouns reach a wider audience, grow in value, and achieve greater impact. I would suggest that they focus on creating more user-generated content, leveraging existing relationships with other DAOs to amplify their messaging, and incorporating the Noggles in a more creative and integrated way.

I like the concept, but I'm not sure that the mobile clinic is a good fit. I think the focus should be on community building and expanding the current scope of Precious Noggles, not necessarily on a medical mobile clinic with recycling. The proposal could be strengthened by focusing on creating a new Noggles design (like "Noggles For Good" or "Noggles for Kids") that would be used for both promotional and fundraising purposes.

This proposal is very ambitious and needs further development, particularly regarding the inclusion of more specific information on how the project will directly connect with the Nouns community and encourage engagement within the ecosystem. The proposed goals, like hosting events and promoting the project through social media, are good, but the proposal could be improved by providing more detailed information about the specific methods they will be utilizing and how they will be integrated with the broader Nouns community.

While we believe the team has made significant strides with the project’s execution and appreciate their commitment to improving the health and welfare of children, this proposal does not have a strong enough hook to align with the goals of the DAO. This proposal could be improved if it is further tailored towards showcasing the Nouns brand and highlighting the role of CC0 in its replicability. It also needs to include more details about the distribution and marketing strategies for the glasses produced.

I’m impressed by this proposal’s ambitious scope and detailed plan, aiming to create a tangible and lasting impact while aligning with the Nouns community’s core values. The project focuses on direct impact, media exposure, and global replicability, which are key factors in driving positive change and expanding Nouns’ reach.

This project aligns well with the values of the Nouns community while also providing a clear pathway for a positive and sustainable impact. I am confident in the proposers' ability to execute this project successfully.

I like the vision presented but would love to see a more detailed plan around engagement with the Precious Plastic community. I think there are ways to deepen their collaboration to make this truly Nounish.

While a mobile clinic is a great idea, we should ensure that the project has a strong local partner to help with implementation. We should also be clear about the intended role for the Noggles. The project should also focus on generating a wider range of creative ideas and use cases to increase the potential for impact.

This project is a perfect example of how Nouns can make a real difference in the world while spreading the values of Nouns further. The project's impact will be much bigger than the amount of funds requested, and I look forward to seeing this play out.

I believe this proposal is not a good fit for Nouns given the amount of funds requested for the scope of work. The impact of the project is not clear to me and I am unsure if this project will be able to proliferate the Nouns brand in the long-term.

I'm concerned that the mobile clinic, while a wonderful idea, is too ambitious of a project to complete within the proposed timeframe. I believe the proposal would be more impactful if the initial focus was on producing and distributing the glasses with future scaling of the mobile clinic addressed in a separate proposal. I'm also skeptical about the amount of plastic waste that can be recycled and the potential to reach 15,000 children annually. I would prefer the proposal to clearly define the initial goal and be more pragmatic with its estimations to ensure greater accountability and transparency.

I think the scope of the project is too broad for a single proposal, and the scope of its long term impact isn't fully explained. The proposal could be improved by focusing on smaller, more concise goals that could be achieved within a shorter timeframe. In addition, the proposal should provide more detail about how the vision will be carried out and how success will be measured.

I am really happy with this one. It's exactly the kind of project I would expect to see Nouns sponsoring: a creative and fun way to improve the lives of others. We should encourage more proposals with high social impact.

This project is bold and imaginative, with a focus on direct impact, global reach, and education, which is key to Nouns’ success. The proposed outreach plan is comprehensive and well-thought-out, ensuring a robust platform to connect with existing and new communities. Also, the emphasis on replicating the project with CC-BY-SA licensing and open-source molds is essential for Nouns’ long-term vision.

The current proposal does not provide a strong enough connection to Nouns. It could be enhanced by featuring Nouns art or a Nouns-themed experience within the mobile clinic. The proposal should showcase how Nouns benefits from this project.

While this proposal is well-intentioned and promotes worthy values, it lacks a clear strategy for ongoing engagement beyond the initial launch and relies heavily on pre-existing relationships. The project would benefit from a more detailed plan for sustainable growth and community involvement.

The proposal makes a compelling argument for promoting education and sustainability, which aligns with Nouns' core values. The project's global impact and potential for replication also align with Nouns' goal of spreading its reach and influence.

I love the overall vision for this project! It's great to see an effort being made to spread the impact of Nouns to new communities and I think the idea of a mobile clinic has incredible potential. Unfortunately, it feels very disconnected from the rest of the Nouns community, and I believe it would be more successful if it highlighted its connection to the broader ecosystem and its shared values.

This is a well-thought-out plan with global ambitions that aligns with Nouns' values of doing good and creating positive externalities. It also has the potential to reach a wide audience and grow the Nouns community. The proposal clearly details how the project will unfold, its impact, and its distribution strategy.

I am unsure how this prop will help the Nouns community grow and think it is not as impactful as many other props. It seems like it would be a great prop for Precious Plastic but it's not clear what the role of Nouns is. I encourage the team to add a more engaging, educational and interactive component.

This is a very exciting project with a lot of potential, but I have some concerns about the scale. It seems like there is a lot of unnecessary fluff surrounding this proposal. This could be improved by focusing on one or two key deliverables with clear targets and timelines. The project can be expanded later if those goals are achieved.

The goal of helping vulnerable children in Rio de Janeiro is important to the cause, especially when it comes to providing eye care and access to education through recycling and sustainability.

This project addresses social and environmental issues in a unique and impactful way, expanding Nouns' reach across several communities. The proposal's commitment to open-source initiatives further enhances its potential for global impact.

This proposal provides an opportunity to positively impact vulnerable communities, leverage the Nouns brand in a meaningful way, and expand its reach to new audiences. I am particularly interested in the initiative's focus on promoting recycling and sustainability, and believe this is aligned with the values of the Nouns community.