wand

I'm excited about the idea of building a long-term, sustainable Nouns GG with a dedicated community and focused on high-quality content. The 2025 plan has clear goals. The proposal lacks clarity around how this will be achieved and the role of the community.

This proposal lacks a detailed explanation of how Nouns GG will operate on a sustainable basis after the initial funding period. I would like to see a more comprehensive breakdown of expected revenue, expenses, and the specific strategies to achieve ongoing success.

While I'm really excited to see Nouns GG grow, this proposal lacks a clear path to becoming sustainable, and the requested funds are too high. I encourage Nouns Esports to focus on one event and then see if the community responds before scaling to multiple events.

I think it's great to keep investing in esports. This one looks well planned and the teams have a lot of experience within the ecosystem.

While I appreciate the goals of the proposal, I believe that the requested budget is too high. I would suggest that the proposers re-evaluate the budget and provide a more concise breakdown for each activity. Focusing on a smaller scope and fewer events can make this proposal more digestible and appealing. This would also make it easier for the community to support.

While I am a big fan of esports and Nouns GG, I believe that these events should be more organically grown without an enormous ask like this. It's unclear to me how a ‘Nouns Bowl’ at the Hall of Fame Village could be impactful. This feels like a great idea for another season, when the community has proven the concept of Nouns GG events.

The proposal feels overly ambitious in scope and lacks a clear articulation of how Nouns GG can truly be a force in esports. The details around specific events need to be more defined to clearly communicate the benefit to the community.

While Nouns GG has demonstrated a positive impact in esports, I am hesitant to commit such a large amount of funding to a proposal that feels less than concrete. If this proposal were broken into smaller, more focused events, I might be more supportive.

This proposal is not explicitly defined and relies on the assumption of a 10+ year lifespan for a particular game. This is hard to predict and doesn't account for the volatility of the esports scene. Providing more concrete examples of events or the exact format of content would strengthen this proposal and make it more concrete.

I believe this proposal is important to the growth of Nouns and would help the community connect with the DAO.

While I love the ambition behind this proposal, the budget is too high for this type of event and I'm worried this might lead to a bad precedent. It would be more effective if the team focused on running a single, more impactful event and used that to attract sponsorship, boosting community and stakeholder engagement. If they can present a smaller-scale but higher-quality event, then I might consider voting for it.

I'm not ready to make this a large commitment for an established program. This proposal needs to be better honed and should focus on community involvement. We should consider the value of community participation rather than just the program itself.

This proposal highlights Nouns's efforts to reach new audiences and further integrate the brand into the esports community. It leverages a successful formula from past efforts and will generate valuable content across multiple platforms.

I appreciate the dedication and effort put into building a platform that aligns with Nouns core values. The team seems to have a clear plan for the future.

The proposed events are all quite large and require a huge budget, a more measured approach would be to first test out these events in smaller communities before scaling to larger events. Maybe the team can identify some smaller but equally passionate communities that could be used for testing.

The proposal is well written and has clear goals, but lacks the depth and concrete deliverables to warrant such a large budget, especially for a team that has not been successful with previous proposals. I would recommend reworking it into a more focused proposal with fewer commitments.

This proposal outlines a clear plan for growth and expansion within the Smash Bros. community. It leverages existing relationships with key partners like Matcha, Tipped Off, and the Hall of Fame Village to create impactful events, expand into new markets, and increase visibility for Nouns. It also emphasizes a strong focus on charitable initiatives, aligning with Nouns DAO's core values of community and collaboration.

The proposal focuses heavily on onboarding, but does not sufficiently describe the proposed onboarding mechanisms. This proposal feels like a general statement of intent and less like a focused action plan. It would be more persuasive if the proposal included detailed plans and specifics about how these activations will be implemented.

While this seems like a good thing to support, the budget is huge, and I’m hesitant to fund such a large investment without proof of concept that shows these events are the right direction.

The proposal is very broad and does not provide enough detail about specific initiatives or potential outcomes. I would like to see a more focused proposal with a clear plan for building a community and driving engagement.

Nouns Esports has done some incredible work in the past two years. I’m eager to see how Nouns Esports will continue to grow, but I think that this proposal is asking for too much, too soon. In order to achieve long-term sustainability, Nouns Esports will need to explore new ways to generate revenue. Would love to see this proposal with a smaller ask, and an emphasis on generating revenue through e.g. NFT drops or community initiatives.

I'm hesitant to support a proposal that seems too broad. Focusing on one event or activity to begin with, and then measuring its success, would be more effective. This would also allow the community to better understand the ROI.

I’m not sure that Nouns has a role in this project, as the benefits listed are not directly correlated with the Nouns ecosystem, nor are they specific to Smash Bros.

While Nouns Esports has been a good steward of the community, this proposal is too broad and should be broken down into individual proposals with specific events, metrics, and goals.

The events listed are well-established within the gaming community and hold a great deal of potential for Nouns Esports. To further improve upon this proposal, the team should consider collaborating with other popular esports groups or projects to create a truly unique experience for the community.

This proposal does not have a strong focus on the core values of Nouns. To improve this proposal I would like to see more emphasis on content creation and a clearer outline of how Nouns GG is going to be used.

The proposal seems overly ambitious and doesn't provide enough detail on how it will generate enough revenue to be sustainable, especially after the changes to its overall budget and requested funds. I'd like to see the specifics of the plan to drive revenue through ticket sales, sponsorships, and merchandise, with a clear explanation of how the team will engage with the community to ensure success.

The budget is much larger than we've seen in the past, even with the added goals and ambitions. The best approach would be to have separate proposals to accomplish these goals in stages.

While I am a fan of the overall work that has been done by the Nouns Esports team, the ask feels too large. It would be helpful to see a smaller ask that demonstrates a more cautious approach to budget spend.

I think this proposal's strategy of focusing on events in the Super Smash Bros scene is a great way to onboard a new generation to Web3. I'm very interested in seeing how the Nouns GG platform continues to grow in 2025.

The proposal is lacking clear and concise objectives. What are the key metrics for success? What exactly is the "impact" that Nouns GG will achieve? A detailed explanation would help make the proposal more convincing. Also, while this proposal is not requesting funds for the development of Nouns.GG, I think we should explore how to ensure the platform's long-term viability. How will Nouns GG be sustained after this proposal? This needs to be addressed.

Nouns Esports has been a valuable initiative and this proposal leverages existing experience and momentum to expand into an exciting new area. Focusing on Smash Bros and building a strong, sustainable program for the community is a compelling vision.

I don't think Smash Bros is the best way for Nouns Esports to engage the community. The content seems generic and would rather see an approach similar to the Hawaii Suite in a different location. It would be great to see a smaller, more focused event, that has some more distinct nounish aspects.

I am still not a fan of rewarding nouns in proposals until the proposal itself has been completed. It feels really odd. Also, I think this feels like too many separate things bundled into a single proposal. The core idea of the "DNA Standard" and the "Nouns GG" platform seems interesting but I think a more focused proposal with less moving parts will be more appealing and easier to vote on.

I see a great opportunity for Nouns to bring its values to the millions of gamers in Smash Bros. with events that go beyond simple brand sponsorship and drive community engagement.

This proposal seems like a repeat of similar esports proposals, and feels very repetitive. The event structure feels very generic and I don't think it's a great use of the treasury given the current state.

Nouns GG is great! I love the vision but don't think the event schedule is well aligned for driving the most impact and bringing people to Nouns in a meaningful way, particularly with limited funding. The schedule and overall feel of the events also seem a bit stale and not really ‘nounish’ - i'm hoping to see something more unique and absurd for the next proposal. 

This proposal outlines the expansion of Nouns Esports and its potential to reach a broader audience. The focus on Smash Bros. events aligns with Nouns' values and offers a clear avenue for further engagement and growth.

While we are fully supportive of Nouns GG and all its efforts, we believe the funding request feels a bit inflated. The proposal does mention a focus on sustainability but doesn't address any specific plan for revenue generation beyond partnerships, ticketing, and merch. Also, the allocation towards Nouns GG, Events, and Staff seems rather high. We would love to see a refined proposal that includes a more detailed plan for generating revenue that would make Nouns GG self-sufficient and could potentially utilize the existing infrastructure already built.

The proposal focuses on building a vibrant and engaging community within the gaming space. The use of Nouns GG and its integrated features will enhance user engagement and incentivize participation, aligning with the broader goal of onboarding a new generation to blockchain. The clear strategy of expanding into the Super Smash Bros. scene, with its existing strong community, presents a promising opportunity for growth and impact.

Given the level of community, project and team support for the Nouns Esports team and the potential for a sustainable revenue stream, I’m unsure what the justification is to fund their next season of a singular esports title. I’d be more supportive of a smaller ask that focuses on a smaller scale, and potentially more sustainable, event with a clear, tangible outcome.

This proposal provides a robust overview of Nouns GG operations and future events, but lacks a clear vision on how they will be executed. Focusing on specific plans for each event, along with their impact, would provide more clarity to voters.

Nouns Esports has done an impressive job growing the brand in the gaming space through multiple game partnerships and events. The proposal is well articulated, and its inclusion of unique events and community features makes it exciting to be part of. The plans for Nouns.GG, specifically its focus on Quests, Rounds, and a dynamic leaderboard, will increase engagement and build a thriving community for the DAO.

I'm excited to see Nouns GG evolve beyond its existing success and create a new, vibrant, and inclusive community for a beloved and popular game like Smash Bros.

I believe this proposal aligns with Nouns' vision for a community-driven platform and would contribute to the long-term sustainability of the Nouns ecosystem. It also offers a unique opportunity to bring Nouns to a new, larger audience.