wand

The proposal is a unique opportunity to tell a story of creativity, innovation, and technology that is a strong alignment to the Nouns DAO. The proposers have experience producing high-quality content for a global audience.

I would support a leaner, more focused approach to the deliverables, with more detail on what the actual artistic output would be. This prop is a bit too broad for the ask.

This proposal is extremely ambitious and I love the overall vision for a Nounish product and film that could potentially reach a wide audience, especially if we can partner with talented creatives from the Nouns community.

Although there are numerous established and prominent figures involved, I am unsure how this proposal will be impactful to the community or result in meaningful proliferation. The proposal would benefit greatly from focusing more on the specifics of how the project will be implemented and providing a clearer framework for audience engagement.

This proposal currently lacks clear milestones and timelines, which makes it difficult to assess the expected impact of this long-term project. Perhaps adding a few interim milestones to the proposal would be helpful.

This proposal brings a lot of experience to the Nouns community with a clear and well-defined plan for delivering a product and story that will resonate with audiences both inside and outside of crypto.

The content produced by this proposal is in alignment with Nouns' aesthetic of creativity and community. I look forward to seeing the film and album, which should generate interest in the Nouns ecosystem.

This proposal will have high impact on a large audience, and the creators are clearly skilled. This seems like a positive opportunity for Nouns to reach more people.

This proposal doesn't sufficiently explore the potential of utilizing the Nouns branding. For instance, by focusing on the album contest, the proposal neglects to integrate a wider range of Nouns community members. The project could be strengthened by creating an interactive experience, allowing Nouners to co-create the album and film through voting and collaboration. This approach would resonate more authentically with the Nouns community, and the project could explore the potential of using NFTs to give Nouners access to exclusive content or behind-the-scenes experiences.

The proposal lacks clarity and depth in the section related to Nouns contributors and its overall plan to onboard the community. The description about working with artists needs to be expanded upon to include more details about what those interactions will look like.

The proposal is a bit overly ambitious in its scope. I'd prefer to see the initial focus be on the film, and then separately on the vinyl album. For example, the album could be released in a more limited way, with initial distribution to the Nouns community. The proposal should also clarify how it will address distribution and marketing, especially as the team has a limited track record with these activities.

This proposal is well thought out and has a good foundation. However, the goal of the film and vinyl album should be to reach a wider audience outside of the Nouns community and beyond the crypto space.

This proposal blends a rich history of innovation with the creative energy of Nouns, creating a compelling narrative that can resonate with audiences both inside and outside the web3 community. It's a great opportunity to showcase Nouns' core values and expand its reach. The team has experience creating viral content and their collaborative approach ensures an impressive product.

A well-researched project that utilizes diverse talent from the Nouns community. It has the potential to reach a wide audience both onchain and offchain, while building upon the history and value of Nouns.

This proposal seems like a great project that could be very beneficial to Nouns. However, the narrative does not align with past projects and could be improved to better convey how this aligns with the values of the Nouns community and the broader artistic sphere. I'd like to see more details on how the project will incorporate a unique and engaging story for those outside of the DAO.

This proposal is interesting and I'm excited to see how this group of individuals will use their expertise to create an iconic Noun-inspired album and film that will resonate with a broad audience.

I like the idea of bringing Nouns to a wider audience via more traditional media and think a vinyl album and doc film could accomplish that.

The proposal does not describe what the film will accomplish or how it will benefit the community beyond being a “celebration of Nouns.” The creators need to clearly define the film's purpose and how it aligns with Nouns’ mission.

It's an interesting concept that would provide value for the Nouns community. It seems like there's a strong team with the expertise to achieve the vision.

The proposal is too general and lacks focus. It would be better if the proposal was narrowed down to the specific deliverables planned for the initial stage. The team could also provide details on how the proposed film will tie back to Nouns.

While I appreciate the intention to create a fun and engaging physical product, I'm not entirely convinced this is the best use of the Nouns treasury at this point. The distribution plan is also lacking and unclear, making it difficult to assess the potential impact on the Nouns ecosystem.

This proposal showcases a strong team with an exciting vision to produce quality content that should be able to reach a wide audience.

While the concept of producing a vinyl album with a documentary is appealing, the narrative focuses too heavily on the family's history and lacks a clear connection to the future of Nouns.

This prop is exciting and has the potential to attract a broad audience, both within and outside the Nouns community. I believe the team has a clear vision and plan, and their demonstrated experience in producing high-quality media and fostering collaborations is a strong indicator of their ability to deliver a successful outcome. The film component in particular has the potential to reach a broad audience and contribute to Nouns' mission of promoting community and creativity.

I'm still feeling concerned about the general lack of clarity around how this proposal will be executed, even though it seems like a cool idea and I would enjoy the product if it were to ship. I'm looking for a more detailed breakdown of the creative process and clear expectations for the deliverables. The community should be able to have a clear vision as to what is being produced before it's too late.

The idea of creating a Nounish vinyl album and accompanying film about the history of this family's company is a compelling way to introduce Nouns to a wider audience. The proposed team has impressive experience in their respective fields and I'm hopeful they will deliver on their promise of high-quality output.

The film seems too long and bloated for what it aims to achieve. We should be focusing on smaller and more impactful projects that reach a wider audience, like more short-form content and interactive experiences for NFT holders.

I appreciate the history of the proposers and their commitment to building impactful media. I look forward to seeing how the team collaborates with Nouns contributors and the final project.

I love this project! It's so exciting and the team has a great understanding of what makes the Nouns community unique. I am excited to see how this project will be able to reach a global audience and make a lasting impact.

While a compelling story and a team with a proven track record, I don't think the proposal fully utilizes the existing talent pool in Nouns. The proposal does not specify which NFT musicians or animators will be chosen, or how these individuals will be selected. This proposal should include more community engagement and a plan for selection process in the next iteration.

This concept has huge potential for reaching a new audience. I'd like to see more details about the film, including details on how it will be distributed and promoted and a breakdown of which media companies are involved. But given the team's experience and strong connections, I'm confident that this is a high-quality initiative.

I love the concept. The team behind the proposal has a clear vision of how to successfully execute it. They also have a clear understanding of the target audience and how to reach them. 

This proposal doesn’t quite capture the same magic of proposals that have passed in the past. I think that the film could benefit from more detail in its plot, including the intended target audience and how the film would be distributed. I am unsure how this film would connect with the Nouns community beyond the initial hype of its creation.

This proposal is a great way to introduce a new audience to the history of media and the transformative power of the Nouns project.

This proposal feels too broad and would be better executed if split into multiple proposals, each focusing on a specific goal or deliverable.

This proposal is uniquely positioned to showcase the power of Nouns and the cultural influence it wields. The film, especially, could be quite compelling for mainstream audiences.

We believe this is an epic story that’s definitely worth sharing. However, we struggle to see the tangible value it brings back to the DAO. We are not sure where the notion to move away from explainer and prop highlight videos came from, but we don’t agree with it. If we want to break out of the bubble, sharing what is actually possible and what’s being created can only inspire foreign builders to participate. We do believe there is a place for the artist series within the content strategy. However, we do not believe it should be the primary focus. Instead of featuring an artist series, we recommend focusing on highlighting funded proposals to entice builders and new members to join the DAO.

This proposal aligns with previous community efforts and showcases creative applications for the Nouns ethos. The team's experience and connections demonstrate the potential for significant impact within the art, music, and film industries.

The proposal lacks clear metrics for success and is mostly focused on activities that happen off-chain and outside the Nouns ecosystem. While the story is interesting, we can do better by focusing on things with more potential for onchain impact.

I'm generally supportive of creating a physical representation of the Nouns. In this case, the proposal is missing a clear plan on how to further proliferate and expand reach of the project. I believe the proposers should detail a specific roadmap outlining how they will onboard the community and drive wider adoption for a greater impact.

I believe this proposal will bring a great deal of value to Nouns through a high quality project produced by a highly capable team. The film and album have a potential to reach a wide audience.

I believe this proposal is a strong effort to build Nouns' cultural presence across the world.

This is a well-structured and well-thought-out proposal that brings together a diverse range of talent. I love the emphasis on storytelling, and the creative team has a strong track record. The film and album have the potential to reach a wide audience and introduce more people to Nouns and its values.

This is a great example of a prop that could potentially reach a large audience in the mainstream. I really enjoy the concept and hope that they can execute it at a high standard.