wand

While I find the concept compelling, I believe the proposal could benefit from a more detailed overview of the artistic process that will be used to translate Nouns into clothing. This will give more context to the individual pieces.

I appreciate the work put into this proposal, but there’s no clear path to ongoing engagement. This would be more impactful if it was expanded to incorporate more members. It would be amazing to see the entire Nouns community participate in this, but it’s still not there.

The proposal has too many steps for the ask. I would suggest a pilot program, creating a smaller collection of only 5-10 pieces. If the community feels it is successful, then it can be expanded.

The proposers addressed past concerns and are open to further feedback, showing a commitment to community collaboration. I think NOUNSSENCE is a super interesting concept that can lead to something unique.

This proposal is not a good fit for the Nouns DAO, as it seeks to establish a fashion line with limited impact and relevance. The proposed scope is also too narrow to be effective, and the team lacks experience in driving a project to scale. While the project aims to be a public good, it lacks a clear path to sustainability. This proposal should be revised to focus on creating a more expansive and impactful initiative that aligns with the broader Nouns DAO's vision for creative innovation.

I think the current proposal is very good. It is focused and has a clear objective. However, I would suggest that the team create a dedicated website for NOUNSSENCE, as this would create a more permanent and accessible platform for community members to engage with the project.

I like this project and think that Nouns needs more fashion-based projects that are thoughtful. I think it’s a great concept but lacks a clear vision for the future and a roadmap for execution. The proposal should include a plan on how the project will grow after this initial release. I’m also not sold on a burn-based system for distributing the NFTs. I think a better method would be to provide those NFTs for free as an incentive for participating in a game, rounds, or something similar.

I appreciate the proposal and love the vision, but the scope of the project is too broad. I'd be more inclined to vote for a smaller project with a more defined focus. I think it's a bit too early to be offering 50 pieces and could be scaled back.

The proposal is lacking a clear vision of how it will provide lasting benefit to the Nouns ecosystem. While the idea of a clothing line is intriguing, there should be more focus on how this project can be scaled and its impact beyond just 50 pieces.

I like the idea of incorporating new creators and expanding the protocol, but this proposal focuses too much on creating a single, limited-edition collection. It would be better to propose creating a framework or resource that would empower more individuals to create their own Noun-themed clothing. This would allow for more creative expression and wider distribution, aligning with the spirit of the Nouns community.

I am unsure if this proposal will lead to significant onboarding and is concerned with the focus on exclusivity. It feels like an attempt to recreate past efforts without taking into consideration previous feedback. I think the project could be improved by shifting focus from creating bespoke pieces to producing and distributing easily accessible merchandise that can be worn by anyone, further expanding the Nouns reach.

While I love the idea of bringing Nouns to the physical world, I don't feel that this specific proposal is the right avenue to accomplish that. Focusing on a smaller initial collection of 5-10 unique pieces, highlighting these in a more in-depth manner, would likely be more impactful and better reflect the project's vision.

I appreciate the initiative to explore a new avenue for Nouns, however the proposal lacks a concrete plan for onboarding more users to the Nouns ecosystem. This is a significant concern for me. As a DAO, we should focus on fostering meaningful connections and participation through compelling activities that engage a broad audience. I also believe that the project would benefit from a robust marketing strategy that outlines specific channels, campaigns, and partnerships to increase reach and visibility. I’m confident that with a more user-centric approach and a more detailed communication plan, this project could be a tremendous success.

The team has made some changes and is on the right track but needs more time to prove their ability to deliver on their vision. A smaller batch of 10 pieces would be a better starting point for their next iteration.

This proposal lacks a clear path to reach a wider audience outside the Nouns community. The project could benefit from outlining a plan to reach new users and share its value with a broader audience.

The creators have clearly taken feedback into account and revised the proposal, addressing key concerns raised in the previous vote. The concept of translating Nouns into physical clothing is innovative and holds the potential to establish a deeper connection between the digital and physical worlds.

I'm a little confused by the concept of translating a Noun's identity into clothing. I would prefer a more explicit and detailed explanation of how this will be achieved, along with more specific examples of how the different parts of a Noun will be translated. It would be helpful to see a visual representation of these interpretations as well. I feel that the proposal could also be improved by showcasing the existing work done by the team, especially the pieces that have been created for the Yellow Community. This would provide a clear and tangible example of the team's capabilities.

I love the overall concept, but I feel like a lot of the budget is being allocated to team compensation, not the production itself. This proposal could be improved by focusing more on the actual creation of the clothing with a slightly reduced team, which would result in a higher quality product for a lower cost.

The project has great intentions and I appreciate the work done but I do not think the proposal effectively communicates the value this project brings to the community. I would be more inclined to vote for this if it was more focused on the creation of a collection that is more in line with Nouns and less focused on the individual pieces.

I love the idea of creating a custom clothing line for each Noun, but I find the proposal's direction lacks clarity. I think it would be more valuable to focus on a smaller-scale pilot to prove out the concept before a large-scale expansion.

This proposal could be more impactful if it included a series of events where people can see and experience the clothing in-person. For example, a digital fashion show.

While the proposal is cool, it feels a little too close to existing fashion proposals in terms of scope and target audience. I’d be happy to vote FOR on future iterations with more distinct designs that can expand beyond the current Nouns community.

I think this proposal would benefit from more clearly defining the brand and how NOUNSSENCE connects to the Nouns community. What makes this clothing line distinctly Nounish? What are the specific ways the clothing will translate the essence of a Noun into physical form?

I think this proposal would be much more impactful if it were focused on a broader selection of Nouns, rather than limiting itself to 50 pieces. This approach would increase community involvement and potentially attract more participation in the long run.

The proposal’s focus on exclusivity is interesting, but I am not convinced the project has enough of a public good focus to be a good investment. It would be more impactful if the Noun holders could co-create designs.

I like the vision, but I'm not convinced that the proposed approach is the best way to translate the essence of Nouns into clothing. Consider showcasing a few examples of the designs, and provide more concrete details on the creative process for a more compelling proposal.

While I appreciate the reduction to 50 pieces, I’m not convinced that this iteration of NOUNSSENCE has the right balance to deliver a tangible and fulfilling experience. I’m not sure that focusing on "the essence of a Noun" is enough to drive the right type of engagement with Nouns and the community in general. I believe the project would benefit from a focus on how these pieces could be worn in conjunction with existing Nouns NFTs, especially in a more social or celebratory setting.

The proposal is interesting and ambitious, the team has experience working with Nouns and it's clear they have a strong vision for the project.

I love the idea of merging physical clothing with digital art. I think this proposal is a little bit too vague. It could be improved by providing more specific details about the clothing line, the materials that will be used, and the creative process.

While this is a fantastically creative project, I am not convinced that the concept of “the essence of a Noun” is a strong enough concept to base a clothing line on. With the addition of an NFT minting and burning system, the proposal feels unnecessarily complex. Furthermore, the limited number of pieces feels too exclusive and could potentially alienate the broader community. I am confident that a more democratic approach to this project would be more successful in the long run.

This is not a hell yes proposal, it's unclear what the design would look like, and there's no clear picture of how this would benefit the community. Perhaps a smaller, more narrowly scoped trial run would be a more prudent approach to starting this project.

I’m not a fan of this particular approach for clothing since it feels too expensive given that there is already a robust market for clothing and it seems like a lot of effort for only 50 pieces. The proposed approach of 1:1 minting and burning is also not a great idea. Instead, I would recommend a public auction to reach a broader audience and ensure that all Nouns holders have the opportunity to participate.

This proposal still feels a little underdeveloped and not quite nounish enough. I think the focus on bringing the essence of the Noun into the clothing is a good starting point, but I would love to see more detail in the design and how the team is planning to represent the specific characteristics of each individual Noun. I also think that focusing on more accessible materials such as knitwear could be really great and easier to produce at scale.

This is still a bit too vague. While a strong argument is made for the uniqueness of each piece, the collection itself is still a mystery. Adding in some visual mock-ups or even a breakdown of the 50 pieces would make the proposal much more convincing.

I don't think this proposal is well thought through - I'd like to see a more detailed plan on how the NFTs will be used and the process behind the "burning" mechanism. Additionally, the proposal doesn't provide a compelling reason why a dedicated Warpcast channel would be more useful than a regular one.

The proposal needs to clearly demonstrate how this project will be sustained and should expand on the value proposition to the Nouns community. What is the plan beyond the initial 50 pieces?

While I like the concept, the proposal could be strengthened by more information on how NOUNSSENCE will be designed, such as the materials or techniques that will be utilized. It would also benefit from an explanation on how it is distinct from previous fashion proposals.

While we support the concept of this proposal, we believe NOUNSSENCE would be more impactful with a greater focus on the design and the quality of the final product, as opposed to the number of garments.

This proposal could be improved by focusing on creating open-source patterns and templates for building custom Noun clothes. This way, all Noun holders can participate in the creation process, instead of just 50.

I’m voting against because I think it’s important to focus on building a community for creators to contribute to this, before building out the actual product. There should also be an emphasis on driving demand before launching a product in such limited quantities. The team can still accomplish their goal by running workshops, making prototypes, and showcasing them on social media.

I like the focus on creating bespoke garments but the proposal lacks clarity on how the team will work with Noun holders to ensure that each piece is a true representation of the Noun. I would be in favor if the proposal described a more interactive process for development that includes feedback from holders.

This is a great idea and a creative approach to using Nouns. However, the proposal lacks specifics about the production process and how it will be monitored. More specifics should be provided before this proposal can be fully considered.

This proposal is a fresh approach and looks to connect the physical and digital realm through a curated fashion collection. I believe NOUNSSENSE could be a valuable addition to the Nouns community.

I love this idea and appreciate how the proposers have carefully considered the feedback from the last proposal. This feels like a truly unique and high quality execution of a fashion project for Nouns.