wand

Nouns GG has had a lot of success in the esports space. They have successfully hosted several events and generated a lot of viewership. Their work to this point has been incredibly impactful and I believe this proposal will only further the growth and impact of Nouns GG.

The scope of the proposal is very broad, which makes it difficult to assess the impact Nouns GG can have. The proposal needs to refine the details, including specific programing for each event, and a more defined roadmap for Nouns GG.

This is an incredible proposal with big goals. Unfortunately, a lot of the elements feel unproven. The best path forward would be to break this into smaller, more achievable and distinct proposals. It is important for Nouns to keep its budget sustainable, and while this prop has promise, I’m not comfortable funding the entirety of it at this time. I look forward to seeing iterations on these ideas in the future.

This is a huge opportunity to bring Nouns into the popular gaming scene and build a cohesive structure for future events. Good work, team!

This proposal has a lot of potential, but without clear metrics for gauging the success and impact of each event, it's difficult to know if Nouns can continue supporting it moving forward. Also, the cost of 3 Nouns should be allocated towards more than just rewards to the community.

This proposal focuses on a specific community, Smash, which has a strong history with the DAO, and I'm excited about its potential to proliferate the ethos to this space.

I love the idea of Nouns GG and its continued efforts, but the proposal feels too expansive and doesn't prioritize the core mission of the DAO. It also makes me nervous that the Nounsvitational is being billed as the championship of champions without established qualifying rounds or clear criteria for who is invited. It feels like a lot is happening too quickly and I'd like to see more focused, specific proposals for events that are already established.

Nouns Esports has delivered incredible content and engagement, showing that they are dedicated to fostering the next generation of Nouns supporters. This proposal demonstrates how they plan to expand their impact by focusing on the Super Smash Bros. scene - an audience that aligns with the values of the DAO.

This prop feels like it's reaching for the sky with its ambition. I'm not comfortable with the breadth of this plan, and would prefer to see a more focused approach.

This proposal outlines a solid plan for building a comprehensive Smash Bros. program. The community involvement and focus on creating unique events shows potential.

I'm not sold on the idea that we need to pay to have Nouns present at every event, but I admire the creativity and innovation. I would prefer a smaller budget, but with an increased focus on generating content that could be shared and enjoyed by more of the community beyond the gaming world, such as a series of videos like "This is Nouns" but for Smash. These videos could help bring in new Nouners.

I think that Nouns Esports has shown that they have been able to successfully deliver on their past proposals. This proposal is quite large and the amount requested is unreasonable for the work that is being proposed. I think that Nouns Esports should focus on smaller proposals like a single event or competition, and not a whole 6 month period of funding.

This is a great proposal, but the community needs more information on how the Nouns GG team will connect to the broader ecosystem and create opportunities for other builders. I'm voting against it, but encourage a re-submission after a period of community engagement to ensure the proposal is a strong and well-rounded project.

I appreciate the proposal's focus on community engagement and the effort made to onboard new users to the blockchain through Nouns Esports. It is very clear that this project is a long-term vision and will continue to grow. I'm excited to see how this project develops.

While this is a compelling vision with a very strong team, I think it needs additional clarity in terms of key events and specific partnerships to make it a Hell Yes.

I appreciate the team’s vision and past efforts. However, this is a large ask for an experiment that is mostly focused on off-chain activities. It is unclear how many of the activations described are actually integrated with Nouns.GG.

I am skeptical about how much impact Nouns GG will have on the competitive gaming scene, especially in relation to the funds being requested. In my opinion, it would be more strategic to focus on the overall community and develop a more robust onboarding system for new members and participants.

I really like the events, and would love to see them happen, but I think there’s a lot of potential for a smaller budget and scope. The team behind this is great though, I’m looking forward to seeing the iteration!

While I acknowledge the team's dedication to building a Nouns esports presence, the overall ask feels too large without a clear and more focused breakdown of event specifics. The proposal's current focus on sustainability is not convincing given the budget and scope.

Nouns Esports has consistently delivered on previous proposals. Their focus on Smash is a natural fit for the community, and I’m excited to see where it goes next.

The proposal needs to further explore and expand on the value proposition and impact of these events on Nouns. More attention should be given to showcasing the value of these events for community members beyond just an entertaining spectacle. The proposal also could benefit by highlighting the ROI that these events generate for Nouns and the larger community.

I am not convinced that the event series is the right fit. The focus on Smash Bros and a single event like the Nouns Bowl seems unnecessary, and I believe it might be too focused and less inclusive than it could be. There is a better way to do this by creating a more diverse and inclusive event. For example, you could have a Nouns Gaming Fest with more events and more games.

I’m very supportive of the work that Nouns Esports has done over the last few years. They have clearly proven that they are able to create high-quality content and events that are engaging and entertaining for their audiences.

I feel like this prop could really use a deeper dive into the community engagement. It's a great idea, but just needs more fleshing out. For example: how do you plan to incorporate the community into each event? What is the strategy to make the community ownership of the GG experience more meaningful?

While I think the idea of sponsoring esports is a solid use of Nouns funding, I don’t think this proposal is a good fit. There is a lot of interesting stuff here but it feels a bit scattered and lacks a clear vision. I would like to see it reworked to clearly define the goals of each event and how it would benefit the Nouns community.

This is a good concept and mission, but I'm not convinced by the current proposal's approach and execution. We need to see more concrete results and metrics before we can allocate such a significant budget. We need more focus on the events themselves, less on branding and marketing, and a clearer roadmap for sustainability.

The proposal has a great vision for building a more robust and welcoming space for Nouns and its community, however it lacks a plan for diversifying revenue to ensure long-term sustainability. It's critical that the project can support itself over time without relying heavily on the DAO's resources.

This proposal exemplifies the type of on-chain community building that Nouns has historically supported, with a thoughtful approach to engaging fans and creating a robust platform for future expansion in the esports space. I'm also a fan of the emphasis on showcasing the Nouns community directly.

The proposal includes an interesting roadmap, a dedicated team, and an in-depth breakdown of their plans to further develop Nouns GG. It demonstrates a clear vision and strategic plan for building on the success of previous seasons.

This proposal is a bold vision that aligns with our desire to be relevant in gaming culture and to expand Nouns to new audiences. The events described feel well-structured and targeted toward a passionate audience. The use of Nouns.GG for community governance is an innovative way to connect fans with Nouns and the wider ecosystem.

I am excited for Nouns GG to continue working with Smash, but this proposal doesn't convince me. Its focus on events feels too generic and doesn't do enough to make Nouns more than a sponsor. It should have a stronger narrative on how this can directly benefit Nouns and the broader community.

This proposal doesn't clearly highlight how it will proliferate Nouns beyond web3. I'd like to see a more detailed breakdown of the offline events and activations with a specific plan to engage with the larger Smash community and leverage the Nouns name to attract a broader audience. I'd also prefer to see a clearer and more concise narrative around the evolution of Nouns Esports and the impact of past proposals.

I think it's really cool that they are looking to engage the Smash community with this proposal. These are some of the most active gaming communities globally and I feel like they have a lot of potential to be super nounish.

The proposal outlines how they are working to create more immersive experiences for the community that go beyond just in-game elements. This is a really interesting, unique, and even somewhat absurdist approach to onboarding.

While the proposal provides a robust overview of how Nouns Esports operates and future plans, it does not provide any particularly compelling arguments for the requested budget. I am not convinced the requested funding is worth it.

This proposal needs more details and a clearer roadmap.

The team behind this proposal has proven themselves to be a strong force in the esports community, and they've shown a deep understanding of what makes Nouns tick. The proposal's focus on community engagement, along with its clear goals, is something I'm excited to see.

While we appreciate the passion and effort put forward in this proposal, we believe that focusing on a singular game to fund a full year of Nouns GG activities at such a high cost feels risky. We would prefer to see Nouns GG focus on events that have a broader appeal and that could potentially reach a wider audience.

This proposal offers a solid plan for Nouns to become a major player in the esports space. The strategy to partner with and build within the Smash community is a natural fit for Nouns.

The proposal is over-reaching in scope and doesn't provide a clear and compelling narrative as to how Nouns will benefit from the sponsorship. It’s also missing a lot of details on how they plan to execute the events and the intended long-term impact. I’d prefer to see a more concise and specific proposal focused on a single event with a stronger, well-defined plan for incorporating Nouns. I also think the budget allocated for events seems quite high for a project that’s largely about spreading the Nouns brand and doesn’t have a specific, clear path for generating revenue, especially when compared to other successful events.

I'm unsure how impactful the proposal is, the content could be better structured to focus on specific projects. Additionally, the Nouns.GG plans for the proposal's future rely on the continued success of $NOUNS. That is highly uncertain and it's a risk that should be acknowledged in the proposal.

I appreciate the work the Nouns Esports team has done, but there is too much focus on large scale events. To be successful, I believe the team should focus on more local events and community activities. More smaller events are more likely to draw in a large audience and give more opportunities for those new to Nouns to get involved.

I believe this proposal is a great initiative but I would like to see the team focus on smaller events at a lower cost that still show great impact and results within the community.

This proposal is an exciting way for Nouns to engage with a broader audience, and I believe it has the potential to become a sustainable endeavor. I am particularly drawn to the combination of esports events and the Nouns GG platform, which could create a compelling narrative and foster a stronger community.